Hallo, ItsJustlittleoldme
Yesterday I had a car accident so i could not leave for Austria.
I've read your message wherein you wrote that a lot of Jw run
away in the middle of conversation.
Please consider (as you know) that all Jw are really busy.
Job...Family...Congregation...Field service...personal study
...ect..ect.., we really have not a lot of free-time to converse
in newsgroups.
Anyway, now I'm really sick. I've problems with my neck and
for some days i can not move the head. (i 've a lace around the
neck...i don not know the English name) BUT i'm here to answer
your last messagge.
I don't want you could say i escaped the conversation, but please
consider i will need a little bit of time for every message
for the above reason.
I WROTE:
Please note that all the men are imperfect. (Rom. 5:12)
God knows that. Since the Churchs are composed by men...
all the Churches are imperfect. Even the Churchs of God.
But,once again, God knows that his Church is composed by
imperfect men. So, or you accept the imperfection inside
Church of God, or you will not believe that God has a Church.
But do not confound the imperfections with voluntary sins.
YOU ANSWERED:
I have a couple of questions for this one:
1.) If god knows that all churches are run by imperfect men,
why would god pick just one group of imperfect men above
all others and state "These imperfect men are going to be my
mouthpiece" whereas all the other imperfect men are tools
of Satan?
ME:
You should ask it to God, not to me!
Why God pick one group of persons (Israel) and state
<<this is my people>> ?
and more important:
Why God guided his ancient people through imperfect men like
Moses or the Judges and not through perfect angels?
(Isaiah 55:8-9)
YOU WROTE:
2.) Is it possible that the 'church' Jehovah was talking
about is not a physical entity, but rather the person? So
instead of having a congregation of church goers that all
belong to a single denomination (JW's, Catholics, Protestants
etc) anyone who professes and believes in Christ Jesus and
what he did for us belongs to a world-wide brotherhood of
Christian? If, as the bible says, you should have a personal
relationship with God through Jesus, why do we even need a
man-made imperfect church in the middle of that relationship?
ME:
I do not think so. The bible is clear. In the first century
there was a real Church of God composed by Apostoles, Elders, ect..
They had meetings and they used to go in field service.
Acts 15:6
Acts 15:4
Acts 15:2
Ebrew 10:25
Acts 20:20
YOU WROTE:
3.) Are you stating that the Roman Catholic Church, or any
other church except the JW's are committing voluntary sin?
How so? How do you know that it is just the imperfections
of the men that misinterpreted what the bible states?
ME:
Do you remember what Jesus stated in Matthew 7: 16-20 ?
and Matthew 7: 21-24 ?
and Matthew 15:3 ?
and Matthew 15:9 ?
and Matthew 15:19-20a ?
The volountary sins I was talking about are the same you
can find in the above scriptures. Nothing more, nothing less.
YOU WROTE:
No, you never stated that you will follow the errors. What
you did state was that you would continue to be loyal.
Loyalty implies that you will follow, and following someone
you believe to have errored is forgoeing your conscience
and is the same as committing the error itself?
ME:
I don't think so!
I repeat my previous question:
could you please explain me 1 SAMUEL 26:11 ?
Was David loyal to the Visible Organization or was he loyal
to Jehovah?
YOU WROTE:
I'll give you an example: Let's say that new light comes out
from the GB (doctrine x).. You disagree with doctrine x,
and even contact the GB about it.. They say, that is the
correct interpretation, sorry you do not agree with us, but
doctrine x stands.
Now, to be 'pleasing to god' you are taught to go in field
service.. So, you go out in field service, and you meet
someone who asks about doctrine x. You now have a choice,
you can be loyal to the organization, and teach them doctrine
x all the while believing it to be in error, or you can tell
them that you do not believe in doctrine x in which case you
would become an apostate, right? So, out of loyalty to the
organization, you now teach or at least support a doctrine
that you do not believe in. To me, that is going against
your conscience, and when the day of judgement comes, and
you have to personally account to Jehovah, what will you
tell him?
ME:
Sorry, but i've never teached things that i do not believe
in! So all the above statements are nonsense.
I don't agree some points of WTB but i never teached them
in Field service or in Congregation. I always discussed them
directly with GB and Elders of my congregation. And MY decision
was to wait until God will clarify that points.
**********************************************************
remember, it is the attitude that makes the apostates
**********************************************************
I WROTE:
I can understand your point of view.
Do you remember king Saul?
Note that i do not want to compare GB with Saul, it's just
an EXAMPLE.
He represented the human organization of God, in the past.
You know that he made a lot of mistakes.
He also tried to kill David. So could you please explain me
1 SAMUEL 26:11 ?
Was David loyal to the Visible Organization or was he loyal
to Jehovah?
YOU WROTE:
Huh? How have you proven to me that the GB is indeed to
lord's annointed? That is your claim, not mine..
How come you apply that to the GB, but not to any other
church (Cathlolic, Protestant, etc)? What is the difference;
all of these you mentioned are mere mortal imperfect men,
doing the best that they can to try to 'reason' from the
scriptures, right? After all, does the GB have any direct
revelation from Jehovah, or just a self-made claim
(via imperfect men) that they indeed are God's mouthpiece?
ME:
....wait, wait, wait a minute!!
I was not talking about GB.
I was talking about Saul that represented the ancient
organization of God. And i'm still waiting for the answer:
Was David loyal to the visible Organization or was he
loyal to Jehovah ?
YOU WROTE:
....Explain to me how you are not:
1.) Shunning ex-members
2.) teaching stuff that you may not believe in (going
against your conscience)
3.) stayed seperate from the 'world'
All of the above is based on a man made claim that they are
god's mouthpiece.
ME:
1- Why did you said i'm not shunning ex-members ?
2- Why did you said i'm teaching stuff i do not believe in ?
3- Why did you said i'm not seperate from the 'world'?
(I hope to have understood in the correct way! If not,
please explain me again with simple words.)
YOU WROTE:
...
What if they are wrong, and they are NOT the lord's
annointed ones? What do you think Jehovah will do when that
judgement day comes, and you tell him that you followed
these men, and he asks you why you followed imperfect men,
went against your personal conscience, shunned your loved
ones, and stayed seperate from the world, and rejecting
people I sent to you because you thought they were of the
world, when in-fact they were from me?
ME:
I will answer...
<<Because ,after Jesus, you did not provide any perfect man
to follow.
Because i've passed 18 years of my life in another religion
and i used other years to study other religions again...but
i found the Fruits of the Spirits only through JW's.
I know they are imperfect (as per myself) but i made this
choice in armony with my studies and my conscience.
So, now, if you want to reject me, i'm ready to die with the
absolutely conviction that i made the right thing.>>
But obviously, I'm sure this conversation will never happen.
YOU WROTE:
...
Please show me divine proof that the claim they make of
being god's mouthpieice (the lord's annointed) is accurate.
Otherwise, it is just their word, and they could be wrong,
as we all know they are imperfect men.
ME:
Maybe you do not remember that your above statements are
exactly the same Jesus was talking about in Matthew 12:38-39.
see also:
Luke 23:8
2 Cor 5:7
John 13:35.... I found this kind of love inside the JW
organization. If you found it in some other organization, ok!
Stay there. But when that day will came, remember that
somebody knocked at your door.
Regards.
Frank
P.S.
please do not consider my late answers as a try to escape.
I've also the other thread with a long message to translate
again!