Okay, you got me here gsx & elsewhere, i have to reply to this one.
The organizations logic is presumptuous, one-sided, and unimaginative, as well as specifically designed to discourage free thought. And as usual the very argument they use in defence of their opinion can be used against it.
"If God did create such beings, he did so before he created Adam and Eve. Such beings either remained faithful to their Creator, or like Adam and Eve, they sinned and fell into imperfection."
Hello people, study a little quantum physics and the new theories, time is an illusion, therefore there is not necessarily any 'before' or 'after' in the spiritual realm. There is also the possibility of multiple realities or dimensions, jesus could have died ONCE in multiple dimensions.
"But that is not Scriptural. The Bible tells us that Jesus “died with reference to sin once for all time.”—Romans 6:10."
Precisely what I'm saying, even discounting adjusted time or multiple dimensions, Jesus might have died fifty-zillion years ago on a far away planet and the 'death' witnessed here could well have just been a reenactment of that sacrifice. Romans 6:10 could in fact be interpreted as an illustration of that very fact! Why else stress "once for all time."
"What if these beings had remained perfect? Well, when Adam and Eve sinned, they were, in effect, questioning God’s right to rule over a world of intelligent physical beings. If another planet existed at that time, a world full of intelligent physical beings who were living harmoniously and loyally under God’s rule, would they not have been called in as witnesses to testify that God’s rule does indeed work? This conclusion seems inescapable, since he has already used even imperfect humans as witnesses in his behalf on that very issue.—Isaiah 43:10."
Why would they presume that? Obviously one realm of creation need not necessarily HAVE ANYTHING TO DO WITH ANOTHER, why do they presume it would? In fact there may be multiple realities and this would not go against 'scripture', it makes sense that each creation would be judged on its own merit. THERE IS NO LOGICAL WAY THAT ANY PART OF THE BIBLE CAN BE INTERPRETED TO DISCOUNT THE POSSIBILITY OF OTHER LIFE!
When god talks about 'the beginning' in the scriptures there is no way of proving he wasn't just talking about OUR beginning, after all what other reference do we need?
You know what? I am really not interested in the idea of extraterrestrial life, mainly because as far as far as I'm concerned it still leaves the big question unanswered. But unlike the WT I am not blind enough to EVER discount it!
If you are really searching for the truth you don't go around discounting shit that you have no real means of proving or disproving!
Let's face it, it is glaringly apparent that they are just trying to discourage free thought, as usual.
The lines of reasoning and scriptures they used could be used to bolster any number of theories . . . they, however, chose the theory that was least condusive to free thought or speculation . . . IMAGINE THAT!
raven101