You just wonder what in the world it could possibly take to make people at least question the appointment arrangement when something like this happens.
They don't question it. The stock "go to" answers are, "Holy Spirit allowed him to be appointed as a test to see if JW's would be loyal and obedient to the organizations arrangement," and, "He met the qualifications at the time he was appointed, but free will let him change AFTER the appointment," Then they stick their fingers in their ears and run away.