I think I see a bigger picture emerging, for me, about this issue. I am a skeptic by nature. I like to think it is because I care about cold hard truth so much. I like to think that my skepticism is healthy skepticism, a reflection of my honest personality. Still, for all I know, it may be pure nature, and very little nuture. My father is a bit of a skeptic as well.
But I bought into the WTBS 100% for most of my life. And stayed vested probably 95% even after I saw some glaring inconsistancies. I now believe it was all a lie, a fraud, a sham, a joke. How could this cynic have missed it for so long? The fact that the majority of the perpetrators are sincere probably helped.
Still, I don't think I have ever been fooled by an urban legend. I guess the difference is that I have never felt more than just a little guilty for questioning the veracity of a human when they try to sell me the absurd (save for when that human has convinced me from childhood that they are passing Gods word on to me).
And yet many, perhaps most, people are taken in by urban legends. I think urban legends, and religions, and Danielle have a lot in common. Not the least of which is that they are believed for the reason that on some level, the believer wants to believe.
What is that great Carl Sagan quote, talking about JW's and the 1914-no armageddon bust? He essentially said, "convicing people to believe the palpably untrue is the chief occupation of religions."
Why would anyone want to believe in Danielle? I wanted to because she looked like a dominating sexy redhead. But I think more likely for the board in general, she embodied a charactature of all that is wrong with our former religion. Rediculous in the face of reason, how wonderful would it have been to force someone like that to see the light of real truth, or, conversely, to hold them up as an example of how hard headedly silly the "faithful slave" has been.
Gloria? I'd be willing to bet that she was the real deal. And I don't think our reaction hastened her inevitable departure from the WTBS(I'm betting on 2.3 years, now. Anyone want to join the pool? I've got Big Ray being gone by 2003). Had we been the cunning, sneaky apostates the WT society makes us out to be, we could have likely sucked her into questioning without her even knowing. I'm not even sure I believe that would be a bad thing to do anymore.
But I don't think very many of us have the energy to keep up a facade anymore. I think we are for the most part just to damn honest.