Sorry for the late response I was out shopping and partying.
I hope you had a good time.
No your wrong Christians have been delivered from those sins that doesnt mean that there would be a very few number that would struggle against such a sin and temptation but as the spirit of God as promised by God, will be working in the hearts of such sinners that they will repent of and leave such practice.
That would depend on your definition of Christian.
Another question. How do you know your religion is not just a man-made religion like all the rest?
This is due to the commercial perversion of the meaning and intention of Christmas. This is materialism that has a dollar centered Christmas. The true meaning of Christmas was always Christ centered.
Others could argue that the true meaning of Christmas has to do with pagan gods. Others will argue it is a family holiday only.
Before you do the reductio please pay attention to the first premise. That is when the church did Christmas the intention was to remove all the pagan worship and its meaning, and its meaning is the key. Just because they had some of the pagan toys of the winter solstice does not mean they used them for the intention of pagan celebration. The intention and the meaning was replaced from pagan definitions and uses to that of the biblical account and intention of the worship of Christ. Now I agree this was not done 100% according to the regulative principle that is Christmas is and how it is done 100% biblical but the intention and meaning is very biblical.
And just because people use these pagan toys today does not mean they are celebrating anything pagan or anything Christian. As you said the intention and meaning has changed. Christmas is rapidly becoming, or has become, primarily a secular holiday.
In short if Christian were celebrating winter solstice and throwing some pagan party on Dec. 24-25 then yes your reductio would stand but since Christians are celebrating the birth of their king and savor Jesus Christ God the son come in human flesh and that has and is the meaning of
Chris
tmas then it is consistent with the worldview of Christianity.
LOL! I am sure Chris is very happy.
And atheists are just celebrating. I see no inconsistency with a atheist celebrating a secular holiday. And even if an atheist celebrated a religious holiday, which I am willing to do, who cares?
Clash, that is the one question you have never answered. Who cares?
First if one were a true atheist then he would true to his assertions and premises that there is no place for religious gods or deities because they dont exists therefore the logical implication there would be no room for religious tolerance and pluralism.
For the closed minded atheist perhaps. Every group has its bigots. Many atheists are more tolerant of different viewpoints, and are willing to respect others' belief systems. And to me, accepting and loving people is more important than militant adherence to some belief system.
Richard
Edited by - Skeptic on 23 December 2002 22:22:45