Posts by ThisFellowCheap

14

Great arguments, play devils advocate for me

by logical1 in

pretend you're a faithful witness and devils advocate these arguments for me to help fine tune them:.

fallacy of perfection:.

"there will be no more sickness and death in the new earth...".

ThisFellowCheap

@logical1, very great logic, indeed! I commend your rational thinking. But, I can assure you, from bitter personal experience, your sharpest sword wouldn't even cut butter with most of the JWs. I can be a very cunning debater, and people say I give the best saleman pitch anytime I wish to pass a message (at least, my university professors tell me so), yet I have tried most of these arguments with JWs all around me, save the infinite argument, but I doubt even that would work, you know why? Because the cognitive dissonance of an average JW is raised to the power of exponential infinite!

But yes, maybe, it could strike a cord somewhere down down their minds, so I commend you once again- powerful arguments you've got!

31

Are you prepared to apologise even when it is not you fault?

by usualusername in

jw
friends

are you prepared to apologise even when it is not you fault?.

.

uun .

ThisFellowCheap

Nope, that would be stupid and hypocritical to me. Sounds like something Watchtower would have one do. But, yes, I could make compromises if it would allow enough peace to let the wrong party realise her/his mistake and then do the apologizing. I wouldn't pay for someone's else mistakes 'cause no one gonna pay for mine!

20

Judicial committee questions

by slimboyfat in

jw
friends

when the elders invite someone to a judicial committee does the person under scrutiny have the right to ask beforehand what evidence will be adduced against him and what witnesses will be called?

in other words is there pre-trial disclosure within the watchtower's quasi legal process?

.

ThisFellowCheap

Never got to know my accuser(s) officially till date! I personally approached someone I thought was my principal antagonist to avoid animiosity that could result from feeling betrayed, but she denied and gave a list of persons she felt were potential accusers, bottomline, she listed a good number of persons I or my girlfriend thought were our friends. Also, the elders did do a good deal of lying, and they insisted on my not keeping notes when they could. Also, when I appealled, they asked if I kept copies of the appeal leter! Had to get thru a humilating process of SSS-type, Gestapo-styled interrogation just because of family and love, and still I got the boot! Wished I just simply didn't go, wished I never gave them those powers over me!

Anyway, rant over. I'd suggest, if you don't have paddies on the JC, or your chances are slim, just don't go!

22

Do Nigerians really have bad reputation?

by His Excellency in

on a recent thread here about an announcement made by the cobe, with the aim of extorting 10 grand from the servant body, different allegations were made that the request sound nigerian?..

.

my question is, do nigerians really have bad reputation?.

ThisFellowCheap

People are people! And prevalence leads to stereotyping. Anyways, proudly NA-I-JA!!!

1

April Fool Easter!!! LMAO

by ThisFellowCheap in

so, the joke goes somewhat like this in paraphrase: an atheist was complaining about the religionists having preferential treament when it comes to religious national holidays, that the christians get their days and muslims and likes and they don't give just one to the atheists.

and up pops the witty christian and say, "oh, i thought that was what april 1st was meant for!".

and i had to gobble that up every year- no, not this year!

ThisFellowCheap

So, the joke goes somewhat like this in paraphrase: An atheist was complaining about the religionists having preferential treament when it comes to religious national holidays, that the Christians get their days and Muslims and likes and they don't give just one to the atheists. And up pops the witty Christian and say, "Oh, I thought that was what April 1st was meant for!"

And I had to gobble that up every year- No, not this year! Ironically Easter Monday falls on April 1st, and ain't that enough clue for all those who believe the ressurrection stories that they are just simply being dumb- even the "calendar" is saying SO!

So, now I guess it's those who believe the ressurrection tales that are the "real" fools now! LOL How the table turns!!

So, I raise my glass to a toast: Happy Easter, April Fools!!!

38

EASTER QUIZ: Where is the missing prophecy Jesus fulfilled?

by Terry in

since today is celebrated by christians all over the world as easter sunday.... here is sort of a puzzle to solve--if you are interested in things such as this.. .

we begin with luke 24:46. we have a claim being made about a prophecy.. speaking to his disciples on the night of his alleged resurrection, he said, "thus it is written and thus it was necessary for the christ to suffer and to rise from the dead the third day.

" that the resurrection of christ on the third day was prophesied in the scriptures was claimed also by the apostle paul in 1 corinthians 15:3-4: "for i delivered to you first of all that which i also received: that christ died for our sins according to the scriptures, and that he was buried, and that he rose again the third day according to the scriptures.

ThisFellowCheap

Well, @AffHawk, I'd be damned if Friday night to Sunday morning is 3 days and 3 nights! Mehn, that's bloody wonderful arithmetic!! Those guys are just blabbing, and I like how they compare one non-event to the other, proves to me that if one didn't happen, likely neither did the other. I mean Jonah and Jesus- don't you smell something fishy!

54

Tower of Babel built by Babies!

by Billy the Ex-Bethelite in

the weekly tms bible reading assignment is not read, or not carefully read, by most of the sheeples.

it doesn't really matter, because the consideration of the bible reading material is one of the shortest parts on the meeting with a limited number of comments, and those comments are restricted to less than 30 seconds or you will get counselled.

over and over, the dubs are told to read the bible, yet the organization gives no real encouragement to read the bible by keeping everyone busy in the recruiting work and using relatively few scriptures in their "talks".. why?

ThisFellowCheap

Marked too!

39

Did the Global Flood of the Bible really happen? Please give evidence

by The Quiet One in

with todays public talk being about the global flood as a real event, please give any information/views that you have on this topic.

evidence either for or against is more than welcome.

thank you..

ThisFellowCheap

Marked too!

2

The Traveler

by Eiben Scrood in

what is life without some excitement, yes, even some danger?

i know the people on the right path care about me and will look after me.

i have tried for many years to follow this path the way i have been told to.

ThisFellowCheap

I'm begin to enjoy your write-up but can't complete it now. It's a good write so far, expect my critique when I am thru with it- I love dissecting a good work!

211

New light Watchtower magazine leaked from organization weeks ahead of general release

by cedars in

http://jwsurvey.org/governing-body-2/new-light-watchtower-magazine-leaked-from-organization-weeks-ahead-of-general-release.

if doctrinal explanations are missing from the article, it is because they are also missing from the magazine.. i would like to give my thanks again to my source for supplying me with the magazine article weeks ahead of its scheduled release.

it showed remarkable courage, because risks were taken.

ThisFellowCheap

Terrific job, Cedars!