Simon,
Those are some good ideas you have about a peer group casting votes. Could be interesting.
By the way, I appreciate your posting Friday's email to you. Again, you are showing what an open minded person you are to expose this, which obviously made you question yourself a little, and ask for input.
Even tho I told you on your other thread that for the most part I am against any "shunning" of anyone...any rule has exceptions. If we view this forum as your "house" and we are all guests here...then you have the inalienable right AT ANY TIME to tell someone to leave your house.It doesn't even have to be entirely impartial(in someone else's opinion) you have that right. I am a pretty tolerant person, but if someone came into my house and say for example...slapped one of my kids...he'd be out the door in 1 second with a sore behind...and never to return. Would people say I was shunning that person? SO WHAT?
Anyway, the point is, delete whoever you want, as is your right. You have shown yourself to be so fair...that I for one would never question your decision.
You da man Simon
think41self
"It is much more sensible to be an optimist instead of a pessimist, for if one is doomed to disappointment, why experience it in advance?"
Amelia Peabody Emerson