Now this has got to be one of the finest and best presented topics in a long time !!!!
So happy to discover 2 at least and there are many more of you - who are Muso's too !!!
Oubliette your presentation is spot on - both Wifey and I [we are both University trained Muso's ] agree
And Compound Complex got a hint elsewhere on this Forum that you too are not only Linguistically sound but sound in music too [Puns intended!]
For years we have said that this song is just like Stella by Starlight but your detailed analysis confirms much more .......! Its a knock-off !
Sorry Neonmadman - while I strongly agree that it is possible for us to inadvertantly pen a piece of music because we just happen to carry thousands of tunes around in our heads I think the "evidence" so well presented here tends to favour a knock-off. Dont be offended. There is another song which sounds like the start of the Aussie National Anthem [Just cant put finger on the name and #]
CC and Apognophos well done on digging up the Mindy Carson / #72 one - Boy you guys are fast..........................this is what happens with a "Diseased Mind" you know !!!!!!
BTW who else here is a musician ?
Regards
Cape Town
South Africa