I've realised after decades of mulling over all kinds of 'what should I do's', 'what should I think' etc, that all I know is what I feel from this minute on. Yesterdays weather is gone and no good worrying about, except in the positive learning it gave you to help you deal with it if it returns.
Love is all that makes sense if it happens to you.
If you don't have a close understanding of God at this minute then you cant say you love him and know what he wants you to do.
You'd like to, just like you'd love that perfect partner to come along and devote your lives to each other in family bliss - a soul mate dreams are made of.
Those two elusive loves haunt voids in ones life and any loving affection feels like an excellent and moreover biologically natural alternative - especially when the two elusive loves are known never to have happened in some peoples lives. This is realtime, there are no second and third takes, So do what feels right and good for you, so long as you don't hurt or break any laws you may then start to enjoy what you are. A human being, one of thousands of species with your own (possibly God given) biology made to do what you're made to do!
There are lots of books of faith and each with their own morality/ ethics as well as hidden/lost faiths with free thinking ideals so who knows for sure.
And if that's a problem on judgement day just ask,
'Was I really supposed to score top marks in that multiple choice about religion, life, morality etc. without ever knowing for sure the book I was reading was the one for the test I was being given? Would you do that to your own kid?