Sincere Question to Anyone who Believes in God

by Big Tex 84 Replies latest watchtower beliefs

  • jgnat
    jgnat

    I think you are on to something, Big Tex. It is your perspective on God that will lead you to either dread or anticipate the future.

    The anger I have towards adults who spoil the young, I cannot tell you. They are interfering with a FUTURE gxxdmmit. And for very many, it is their parents who give them their first impressions of God. After all, if your own MOTHER found you unlovable, how could GOD?

    But of course, Big Tex, you proved them all wrong. You are a wonderful, caring, whole human being. You are a good husband. You are good, good, and lovable.

    I don't know why God allows bad things to happen. It's the first thing I intend to ask when I see Him face to face. Since I cannot reconcile an all-powerful God with an inactive one, I fear that God is NOT all-powerful. He has limits.

    My perspective is that God IS intimate with all I do good and bad, but that His interest extends past that of an accountant. I am immersed in the thought that God loves me all-in-all, loves mankind, loves all little children. I console myself, as another poster has suggested, that God will give those evil people (the ones who are cruel to children) their just reward one day.

    So you could say that I see the end of every man's earthly life to be the day of ultimate justice. But I am not afraid.

  • mouthy
    mouthy

    With my luck I'll either be forgotten in Heaven's waiting room,
    Well I am sitting outside Heavens waiting room Tex.And MY prayer is for you. I can understand where you are coming from Since you had unfair Parents ,you cant identify with a GOOD FATHER
    The example wasnt there.
    The ONLY reason I believe in God is. from what I see -not man made but Creator made... Oceans,trees, babies,animals I could go on & on but you get the picture. What life has done to me. You dont want to know, but what I have done to life is worse.!!!!I messed up Millions of times, Yet I believe that when I got on my knees & asked Christ to become a part of me.1989.. He did, I still mess up,But from MY understanding it is how I behave with MY kids -is just a portion of how HE behaves with HIS adopted kids ( US)...Boy!!! my kids have messed up on MANY occasions,
    But I was always there for them, so was my unbelieving hubby-
    When I was 15 I messed up MY parents chucked me out...
    .but when Mine messed up I helped them ,still do to Grandkids, & Great grandkids now. & I am a SINNER!!! I believe who ever made the trees sun, moon, flowers is much more forgiving than old Grace Gough...
    Yet I wouldnt hurt my kids for the world. .I could slap them up the side of the head often when they screw up...( I dont but would like to) I think God is a MUCH MORE LOVING DAD!!!! than we can even understand..... Sorry to ramble darling. but Have you invited Christ to live with you? What have you got to lose? Your feeling low, discouraged,but if you cant>>>>.. While I am sitting outside the waiting room I will keep mentioning your name to the receptionist

    .

  • codeblue
    codeblue

    (((Big Tex))) You do not sound stupid......at all....stop that thinking!

    I don't claim to have answers just "feelings".

    I guess being raised a JW and living it till I was 46.....I always chose to think of God/Jehovah as a loving parent. As a parent myself, I would never torture my kids if they disappoint me or quit loving them. Maybe that is why I am NOT a JW because I believe in the course of what "love" dictates.

    As far as death and what happens....I guess I dwell on the scriptures about Jesus viewing Lazarus as sleeping...before he resurrected him. I hope it was a "restful, non night- mare sleep however". (I have been having many nightmare's lately when I don't take my anti-anxiety meds.....so I know what night mare sleep is and how unrestful that is)

    Viewing my answers as a loving parent, I chose to believe God/Jehovah would never torture me for my errors in my life, cause after all...I wasn't created perfect. OOPS, I just said that earlier. I often thought of an assembly program where they illustrated how kind and loving god is comparing it to a child who woke up at night, was scared. He ran into his parents bedroom crying and his parent scooped him up and gave him a hug and listened without scolding or belittlement. How comforted that child felt and how secure and loved he felt.

    I don't know why I have had so many bad things happen in my life. I know you have endured much heartache and atrocities.....For that I am deeply sorry I don't think God caused them at all. I have no answers as to why we have had to go through so much in life. In your case, much more then me.

    I hope somehow this answer helps...

    Regardless, I certainly can't wait to see you and Nina at the crawfest and have a good chat

    see ya soon,

    Codeblue

  • LittleToe
    LittleToe

    Tex:

    (1) He/She is the ultimate accountant/lawyer who has kept track of every misdeed, every misstep, every error, every "incorrect" thought I've ever had in my miserable and pointless life; or (2) that God is like the CEO of IBM or Microsoft -- basically this disconnected, arbitrary and uncaring manager .

    You've offered the WTS option and the Deist option, but what about the "Grace" option, that we never learned as JWs?

    You're far from stupid, my friend. Let me simply ask you this: if a daft wee Scot like I can love you, then why not God?

  • Big Tex
    Big Tex
    We go where the white goes when the snow melts away

    As I said, obvilion would actually be easier, and frankly almost welcomed. At least it wouldn't hurt and to quote Daffy Duck: "I don't like pain. It hurts too much."

    The only thing that exist before me at this point and time, is my being able to die a better death. I truly wish for " A Good Day To Die. "

    I hear you prophecor. I'm not afraid of death, truly. Don't get me wrong, I don't want to shuffle off this mortal coil just yet, but I recognize that one day it will happen and this thread is my poor attempt to begin to understand where I fit in afterward. I've had 3 very poor examples in my life of people who were terrified of death and their last few months and years were a misery both to themselves and to those who cared for them. I think death is hardest on those who are left behind, and I cannot make my loved ones' lives more difficult. As Anthony Hopkins said in "A Lion in Winter" when asked what did it matter if he died a coward, his character said: "When all that's left is how you go out, it matters."

    Get yourself some good weed and then get yourself a piece of AbraCaBubble candy/gum

    Never tried it, but it's tempting.

    We all play with the cards we are dealt

    Yeah, and I'm honestly not trying to whine about what I've been dealt. But I do want to recognize that these experiences have influenced how I feel about the afterlife, an afterlife which might very include a Higher Power giving me The Look (among other things).

    Frankly the only reason I believe in God is that I believe with all my heart that there is a Satan/Devil/Beelzebub/whatever. And if so, then there must be a counter-weight. Where there's a yin, there must be a yang. But my logic stops there and emotion takes over and I cannot conceive of any way possible for that Higher Power to even know I exist, must less give a tinkers dam. Which is okay in this life, playing the hand I'm dealt and all that, but what happens then when I die? If that Higher Power doesn't know or care am I screwed again? Don't much fancy that, which is why the atheist answer is more comforting than the religious answer. I'd like to believe the religious answers, but life experiences get in the way making belief nearly impossible.

    I've already tried to believe something with all my heart because it was comforting. I won't do it again unless there is more proof than random platitudes written millenia ago by a bunch of backward shepherds. Those words might very well be true, but if so they apply to others and not me. I am convinced I am forgotten and ignored, or worse, cursed.

    Know that you are always in my thoughts and prayers.

    Jeff S.

    Thanks Jeff, that's very kind of you. I might just take you up on that after I reformat my computer (bloody trojan spyware!) before it crashes. But I must warn you, I know what the Bible says and reasoning from the scriptures doesn't mean much to me.

    Does God care? Did Jesus care? Read the Gospel accounts and imagine you are there

    I have read the Bible cover to cover 3 times. I've read separate translations from the New World JW garbage and I think it's a beautiful message that applies to everyone but me. Oh maybe not every single person, I don't claim to be so arrogant as to know how God feels towards others, but it bloody well doesn't mean me. Which, as I say, I can handle in the here and now. I've made my peace with it, and it's cool. Don't like it, but I can't change it.

    Nowadays I find that listening out for silence helps me - it really does - at the very least it stops me thinking

    Satanus recommended silence as well. Thanks for reinforcing the idea. The nice thing is I go in with no expectations so there will be no disappointment, you know?

    Life sucks, but there can be some good moments

    Of course! There have been many wonderful, fantastic moments in my life. I don't want my dark musings to led you to think otherwise. But really this thread, for me at least, is more about wonderings about the inevitable future.

    on judgement day just ask,

    'Was I really supposed to score top marks in that multiple choice about religion, life, morality etc. without ever knowing for sure the book I was reading was the one for the test I was being given? Would you do that to your own kid?

    When I was in therapy, my last (and best) therapist told me that when a very small child first hears the concept of God they oftentimes will imagine their daddy floating in the clouds. And once we reach adulthood, very often we imput to God some (or even many) qualities/characteristics/personality traits our father has. This is one of the more subtle, and damaging, parts of child abuse. It wrecks incredible spiritual damage.

    When I was very little (perhaps 3 or 4 years old) I used to stare up at the stars and try to imagine which one I came from. That was a period my daydreams were that my real (and loving) parents had visited this world and left but they forgot me and so I got stuck living with a couple of monsters. I used to tell myself that one day they'd remember me and come back for me.

    Which is why I've mentioned some of what was done to me. I'm honestly not looking for pity, but I do recognize logically that those experiences have, in all likliehood, influenced me and my beliefs about God and therefore what happens after death. Therefore I thought it best if I could step outside my head and listen to "normal" people to see if it helped.

    So until you are able to see this life, and yourself in a more positive (and deserving) manner, you will always struggle with this concept.

    This is the conclusion I came to myself. And I am afraid the question this thread poses will continually be my albatross until I die and find out. I just hope whatever he does to me doesn't hurt. Just erasing me from existence really wouldn't be that bad.

    I agree with Satan, learn to meditate. The simpler the meditation the better.

    Thanks poppers. I will try what you suggest. Satanus is one of the most underrated posters this board has ever had, and someone I also read.

    I don't believe that God would be so unjust as to ignore the struggles and confusions that people have here on this earth.

    But he ignores pleas for help. He ignores children who are left with monsters. He ignores adults who fight and struggle just to survive only to get knocked down again and again. If he ignores me now, how can I come to believe he won't ignore me then? And if he does ignore me then, what happens? This ties in my idea that God is a corporate CEO. Do you think the CEO of IBM gives a shit about some spare in the mail room? My experience is the big do not know or care about the little. I'd like to think otherwise, but I have no reason to and I refuse to believe something just because it's comforting. I want to know what's real, not fantasy.

    It is your perspective on God that will lead you to either dread or anticipate the future.

    The anger I have towards adults who spoil the young, I cannot tell you. They are interfering with a FUTURE gxxdmmit. And for very many, it is their parents who give them their first impressions of God. After all, if your own MOTHER found you unlovable, how could GOD?

    But of course, Big Tex, you proved them all wrong. You are a wonderful, caring, whole human being. You are a good husband. You are good, good, and lovable.

    I don't know why God allows bad things to happen. It's the first thing I intend to ask when I see Him face to face. Since I cannot reconcile an all-powerful God with an inactive one, I fear that God is NOT all-powerful. He has limits.

    My perspective is that God IS intimate with all I do good and bad, but that His interest extends past that of an accountant. I am immersed in the thought that God loves me all-in-all, loves mankind, loves all little children. I console myself, as another poster has suggested, that God will give those evil people (the ones who are cruel to children) their just reward one day.

    So you could say that I see the end of every man's earthly life to be the day of ultimate justice. But I am not afraid.

    Janet your post really resonated with me. Thank you. I too have thought about your fear that God may not be all-powerful, which led me to my other belief/possibility about God: that he's a bean counter, an accountant or lawyer who miserly keeps track of errors. Personally I prefer thinking of God as a CEO, someone who can intervene but chooses not to. The idea that God doesn't intervene because he can't is my worst case scenario, and if true, I'm seriously screwed. My best hope then would be for complete erasure, but the meeting or judgment or whatever it would be called with the God accountant/lawyer would not be fun.

    I wish I could believe that evil will dealt with, believe me I do, but I can't. It's not dealt with in this life, so why should it be in the next? God does not bring those people to task here, why should I believe he would then? My mother got away with it. My father got away with it. My grandfather got away with it. I've been set up twice at 2 different jobs and ended up taking the fall for others who skated free. Nothing happened to them. Jehovah's Witnesses across 3 towns and the City of Dallas villified me for 2 years for things my mother lied about.

    I'm not looking for pity, I just mention this because I've never seen karma working in my life. I'd like to think the Buddhists have something there, and maybe karma works for others, but it damn sure don't here. And justice? Well that's the only thing I am afraid of. I truly, honestly, deep in my heart do not think there will be anything approaching justice, only that whatever happens (if there is someone judging me) will play out like the above.

    The ONLY reason I believe in God is. from what I see -not man made but Creator made... Oceans,trees, babies,animals I could go on & on but you get the picture.

    Grace you sound very much like my wife Nina. This is her philosophy as well.

    Can I ask you something? I know you've had a rough life, and please believe me I know my life could have been much worse (I'm very lucky compared to so many others), so then how did you come to believe in a Higher Power that cares? Because it seems to me, at the end of the day when all is said and done, we just have to make a choice to believe a certain way. And honestly Grace, for me that's just not good enough. I've been fooled once -- twice actually because I foolishly made myself believe my mother and father really did love me but what happened was my fault.

    So see, I don't want to get fooled again. You know, once burned twice shy and all that.

    Geez I sound like Scooby Snax used to don't I?

    (((codeblue))) Yeppers, I'll be there.

    Chris

  • minimus
    minimus

    Big Tex, if YOU can get the answers to these age old questions, please share it with me. I'll be waiting.....

  • Big Tex
    Big Tex
    You've offered the WTS option and the Deist option, but what about the "Grace" option, that we never learned as JWs?

    That's intriguing Ross. But how do I know it applies to me? As I told Grace, I've been fooled before and I absolutely refuse to be fooled again. How do I know the "grace" option isn't something that's either:

    (1) a lie or a trick;
    (2) ethereal and intangible, you know sort of like that's a nice idea but ...";
    (3) how do I know there isn't some codicil somewhere in this grace and I find the rug pulled out from underneath me? It's been done before; or
    (4) absolutely, positively does not apply to me. Why? Well .. because it's me. I've experienced a different set of rules my entire life, rules imposed on me not by me.

    You're far from stupid, my friend. Let me simply ask you this: if a daft wee Scot like I can love you, then why not God?

    'cause I got dead sexy legs?

    Okay seriously, leaving aside my anxities about the concept of grace let me just try that on and then project forward a bit. So what does that mean when I die? If I accept this concept it doesn't make this life any easier, and I'm uncertain what it means for the future.

    Am I making much sense?

    Chris

  • Terry
    Terry

    I keep asking myself: How do you hide something as large as the SUPREME BEING? How can mundane things be so visible and yet not their maker? Haven't humans enough problems already without having to "imagine" God? Just believing "IN" god won't get you far. You have to shop around for the best bargain in which/what kind/ how many, too. There are more kinds of Christians than there are ants at a picnic. They will all agree on only one thing: THEY are right and the rest aren't! Such certainty in the face of a hidden God and an invisible creater is just stupefying. They remind me of poker players that push All-IN on a trash hand and hope the cards fall their way.

  • greendawn
    greendawn

    At the risk of being accused of exploiting the unprovable: the vast majority of mankind is alienated from God that's why God doesn't interfere in the affairs of this world, mankind basically rejected him even those running Christian institutions, despite their lip service. If they had accepted the gospel this world would have been a very different place, since long ago.

    Things will not improve until the Kingdom of God asserts its power over the world and begins to interfere in the affairs of this world. Until then we live in the ruthless times of the nations where God only cares about keeping a minimum of decency and order.

  • LittleToe
    LittleToe

    Chris:

    But how do I know it applies to me?

    Because it's the only version that makes any sense of you feeling stupid, insecure and worthless and yet accepts and loves you as you are "warts and all". Simply put, you inately "know". I can't give you that knowledge, no-one can. But you can accept it and see what the result is to your psyche. As previously advised, "be still" and let it flow to you. This is an experiential thing, not a conscious mind-logic thing. You can't work it out in your head - you have to "just do it" for it to have any meaing at all.

    Let me put it another way, accepting the premise that there's a God and an afterlife:

    • If God is an accountant with no substitute to reconcile the books then we're all screwed, coz we can't live up to such exacting standards.
    • If God isn't really that interested in us then it's all pretty meaningless, and any afterlife is surely arbitary.
    • If there is a God that gives half a d*mn then He's probably done it all already, so what does He want from us?

    If all He wants if for you to merely accept what He's attempting to give you, then it's hardly that onerous. Take it, give a nod of thanks and "don't worry, be happy".

    If there's one thing I know about you, Chris, is that you are a big-hearted, kind soul. You continue to wrestle with this question, refusing to let go of your original premises. The last option ("grace") is the one that appears likely to give you the greatest peace in this life, and a fair crack at the whip at the one to come.

    Just my 2p.

Share this

Google+
Pinterest
Reddit