I am simply blown away by your reasoning or lack of reason. Also inability to read coherently what I said.
The statement made by Rosalee was that there are lots of dubs, who went apostate and then returned to dubdom. It is simply not true and is paramount to saying the moon is made of cheese.
How in the world would revealing who these contrite and penitent "former apostate" persons who have already been df'd, then reinstated, be harmful to them (or anonymous Rosalee) any more than posting the name of someone from your Allen Texas congregation who was df'd for adultery 10 years ago and long reinstated and remarried? If she offered as proof of her claim the name "Bill Watson" of the "SF bay west congregation" who was df'd in 82 for apostasy and then came back in 1992, went to the meetings until 1994 when he was reinstated and has been a loyal witness up until the present, how would that testimony put anyone in harms way?
The local elders of Bill Watson are going to hear about rosalee's post on JWD and re disfellowship poor Bill Watson? You are an idiot if that is your argument!
Now if the people she is speaking about were "secret apostates" that only "thought" apostate thoughts in a closet, we would then be talking a different matter and you might have a point. There are at least 6,000,000 dubs who fit that off the topic profile.
You and the gnat are just on a totally different wavelength and seriously lack reading comprehension.
There are creeps on the world wide web? No doubt! What does that have to do with substantiating a claim made. Naturally you totally ignore the comments made about the lack of any JW circus over such a trimphant victory. If what Rosalee says had happened just once, that person would be so well known this discussion board would need no fear of revealing their name.
You guys remind me of the brain dead divwacks at Canada Bethel that I asked why I wasn't being told who my accusers were. The answer was "the elders cannot reveal those names as they are protecting those people from possible reprisals". What might that be? Some "creep" might send them a nasty letter, leave a rude voice-mail on their phone?
You want to play emperors clothes with her, be my guest. No need to turn on me for being.....
Frank75