A PUZZLING QUESTION...????...????...????

by Terry 110 Replies latest watchtower beliefs

  • writetoknow
    writetoknow

    Here what I mean about double standards.

    1.) It is repeated and stated on this thread that God is not real He is man made and so is His word the bible. Yet He is hated for those stories written by men in the name of a God - so why should these stories bother you if they aren't real.

    2.) It is claimed on this thread that the bible was stolen from pagan beliefs. Then who wrote the stories of Job and Christ the pagans or believers in God?

    So who are we blaming, if God does not exist, the magical pie in the sky. Or the reflections of our own hearts.

    If paganism is the only thing that is real and everything was taken from their teachings who are we hating pagans or a make believe God or Christian that stole those stories?

    Are we any smarter then past generation when we talk in circles?

    So is about blame; people must have someone to blame for their problems most often that is express in hate. Why is everyone so mad at the unreal pie in the sky? Don't you love kids that have all the answers in their limited 20 some year of life.

    How much better they do the job then their parents. Hey sometimes the kids are right but the process of growth doesn't start until the hate stops.

    Now we know why people killed Christ they really were killing themselves.

  • LtCmd.Lore
    LtCmd.Lore
    1.) It is repeated and stated on this thread that God is not real He is man made and so is His word the bible. Yet He is hated for those stories written by men in the name of a God - so why should these stories bother you if they aren't real.

    For the same reason that people get angry at Emperor Palpatine or the Borg, sure they're fictional beings, but they're also jerks.

    Another reason is that a lot of people acctually BELEIVE in this fictional creature.

    And another reason is that a lot of these people who believe in him acctually LIKE him?!

    So imagine if everyone you know, believes that Emperor Palpatine exists, and they also believe that he's just the swellest guy you've ever not met! And they generally get ticked off at you for believing he's fictional...

    So yeah, we know God doesn't exist, but we also dislike the concept. And if I ever met someone who believed that the Jigsaw Killer was both real and tottally awesome, then I'd probably do my best to point out how ridiculous that really is as well!

    2.) It is claimed on this thread that the bible was stolen from pagan beliefs. Then who wrote the stories of Job and Christ the pagans or believers in God?

    Romulus was the son of God, born to a mortal human virgin. Dionysus turned water into wine. Apollonius of Tyana raised a girl from the dead. Jesus Christ was the son of God, born to a mortal virgin, turned water into wine, and raised a man from the dead.

    The writers of the gospel obviously borrowed a lot of ideas from pagan religions while they were inventing Jesus' history.

    I.E: http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Dionysus#Parallels_with_Christianity

    Lore

  • writetoknow
    writetoknow

    Kinda sounds like kids my dads better then yours! So really you just made my point people like shedding blood in the name of god/God/Paganism/Government/Big Business whatever, but its a whole lot easier to blame someone else but themselves.

    There no subject on this earth people cannot argue both sides of the issue and claim they have it right. There is no moral sickness that humans cannot justify if the want to do it. (that doesn't mean it right because a person can argue point.)

    Thats the reason the bible say all men are liers and their hearts are treacherous. Furthermore, we all read other peoples thoughts and vehemently argue the point and some are willing to kill for mans thoughts.

    So the questions is what is the person motive? When that it found out then you know the reason they will die for a cause and kill for a cause and shed much blood for that cause. The reason people come together in groups is to create an order so something can get done. Rules and laws don't allow for everyone personal feelings and it forces a forward movement to accomplish something rather then everyone personal opinion that becomes the rule of law.

    Does the group have anything to do with God? Perhaps some of it does perhaps most of it don't. Does that mean people know God's thoughts because of the group? Well you stated the things are so obvious - where those that believe in God got their information from. Well if everyone has an opinion and people have motives what can anyone believe?

    And that's point isn.t it, this forum has mainly X JW's on it I am one myself. We were dupe into believing religious doctrine that wasn't true. What was are motive for getting involved with a black and white group in the first place? Was it to serve God or be right on every subject? Many were brow beat into submission because everytime they had a question there was an answer. Some thought yea man I am special I like the idea everyone else being wrong and we are the only ones that have it right.

    Theres thousands of people that live a lie rather then leaving the group. The ones that go or are disfellowship are so overwhelmed that if JW's didn't have the truth there can be no truth or there can be no God.

    Few of us probably got on our knees and ask God what He wanted in the first place what is the truth according to Him not man? Why because we honestly believed God decieve us. Jehovah Witnesses were taught to hate all other religion and put them down judge them and mock them and they are proud of it. What left after you go that way nothing! Amazing we used the bible like a big maginfying glass to see all the imperfections in other religous groups.

    Few of us learn love, peace, kindness the fruit of the spirit. So what can they think if they hate and find fault with all groups then 1 + 1 = 2 then thats the way God feels about religion and man. Most aren't open to any further understanding of God they had the so called truth.

    So what does a person do that has a vacuum and the believes they have the right to judge all other religions on earth and their religion is taken away? Do they learn to be more balance from the experience of inbalance. Do they learn to listen to God or man from the experience. Do they learn to be fair and more tolerant. Do they listen to people they once judge as less then human and learn that they to hold their belief with great conviction. Do the realize that God has also been misrepresented by their actions and the groups. Do they honestly seek truth and spirit instead of law and judgment and doctirne. Do they learn that all men come together in groups toget things done and the motives are usually good and for good works. Do they stop judging once they learn if they had been mislead perhaps many other have been just as mislead.

    So each person stating so called fact on this thread also has a motive and that motive was formed by experience. So the big pictures is man's history cannot be argued away on this thread or in any book it is written in blood.

  • quietlyleaving
    quietlyleaving

    Terry

    Narkissos' point below got me thinking

    If the old God-Man Passion show has worn out, there must always be something else going on another stage of the "theatre of cruelty".

    maybe I'm way off beam here - but it seems to me that today we have weapons of mass destruction that can incinerate not just humans but also the world we live in. The other stage of cruelty - I prefer the former -

    Why aren't Christians embarassed?

    the god-man passion is less embarrassing.

  • eclipse
    eclipse
    What was are motive for getting involved with a black and white group in the first place? Was it to serve God or be right on every subject?

    Just wanted to point out, that many of us were born into the JW religion and that was all we knew, and we raised to see it as the only true religion....

    The people who studied as adults are duped into it because of the wishful thinking to see their dead loved ones again/paradise/the carrot......they don't realize how black and white this religion is until it's too late....by then cognitive dissonance is in full effect, and their ability to question what they are taught is pushed down deep into their subconscious.

    There are JW's that are pompous asses and black and white thinkers, this religion sits very well them, and I doubt they ever leave.

    But to most fair minded people, and those of us who have left the JW's, are probably not black and white thinkers...they saw what was wrong with the JW religion and woke up.

    ****slowly backs away from writetoknow****

    leaving now

  • Terry
    Terry

    Terry

    Narkissos' point below got me thinking

    If the old God-Man Passion show has worn out, there must always be something else going on another stage of the "theatre of cruelty".

    maybe I'm way off beam here - but it seems to me that today we have weapons of mass destruction that can incinerate not just humans but also the world we live in. The other stage of cruelty - I prefer the former -

    Why aren't Christians embarassed?

    the god-man passion is less embarrassing.

    How many murderers simply say, "I hated so and so and wanted them dead."?

    We get: "I heard voices".

    "God told me to do it."

    "They were infidels and deserved death."

    Always an excuse; an "other" involved to share the motivation.

    In point of fact I'm still puzzled why God had to appease God with any process of Atonement.

    When we are "saved" we are saved from GOD! (God's wrath comes from God, after all.)

    Jesus died to appease his own Father!

  • Terry
    Terry
    Thank you for the fascinating lesson in etymology. It entirely makes up for the denigration of my faith.

    Now, don't go all pouty and wounded on me!

    Your faith comes from within you. I can't touch it and neither can anybody's denigration.

    You can't become a victim unless you are physically damaged.

    I work with a group of Pagan, Wiccans, and Witches, believe it or not!

    I also work in the Metaphysics section of a bookstore. I regularly shelve thousands of books about these subjects and I read through them casually on my break.

    Belief and Faith can have ANY object. But, it all devolves down to one question:

    WHY AREN'T YOU ENOUGH? Why do you need outside agency to empower you?

    Christian, Wiccan, Jew, Pagan, whatever-----see themselves as mere nothings until the empowerment from "other" lifts them up and puts starch in their collar.

    There is always an incantation (prayer), ritual, process or group to busy one's self with!

    It makes me think of the WPA during WWII. But, at least they got something useful built while they were being kept busy.

    What spell has a witch ever cast that amounted to gnat spit? What prayer ever stirred a breeze?

    Sacrifices, spells, prayers just keep you busy when you could be doing something actually useful.

    I'm not picking on YOU. I'm just responding to the drone of defense which props up process.

  • Terry
    Terry
    First, the Almighty did not sacrifice his son so some crops would grow.

    Second, when humans sacrifice other humans they cannot raise them from the dead - this fact, as you apparently understand, changes the meaning of the sacrifice

    First, it is a difference of degree and not one of process.

    Second, a sacrifice implies giving something up. The Jesus scenario is all gain and no loss.

    , YHWH again put at risk his Godship, he believed in his son, that his son would "downgrade" himself to a human then as a human undergo his own torture and death on behalf of the very people who tortured and killed him - YHWH believed this but his son did not have to do what YHWH believed - he could have turned his back on his father and humanity - he did not -

    God is "god" beyond anybody's ability to change. If humans are "beneath" "below" or "inferior to" God you can thank the Creator for that state of being. What humans lacked were what God refused to grant them. If God could "create" a son equal to himself he could have created other beings not lacking anything. Jehovah created humans deliberately LACKING in several aspects. These aspects became what immediately percipitated their "fall".

    Man did not "know good and bad". Man wanted to be like the Heavenly Father. Man was placed at a distance from the family of God even in man's so-called "perfection". Man had no mother, no childhood, no nurturing and only estrangement even under the idyllic conditions of pre-fall Eden.

    Wake up and smell the coffee.

    Adam was alone in his species. He could not enter heaven where even Satan could come and go long after "sin" destroyed "perfecton". Adam was odd man out.

    Adam, we are told, had to wander alone among lesser creatures without a mate. How long? Who knows? The "wife" given Adam certainly wasn't a process of choice among others, was it? The bible hints at a choice of animals vs woman. Ha!

    When both Adam and Eve seek to be like their heavenly father the separation of God and human widens to include the gulf of, not only death, but; the death of every offspring from then on!

    You have to look at the BIG PICTURE and ask yourself if this is a story of historical fact or a trumped up fantasy attempting (lamely) to explain why humanity is in the state of pity it finds itself in.

  • quietlyleaving
    quietlyleaving
    How many murderers simply say, "I hated so and so and wanted them dead."?

    But, but not everyone who harbours hate goes out and kills someone

    We get: "I heard voices".

    "God told me to do it."

    "They were infidels and deserved death."

    Again a small minority

    In point of fact I'm still puzzled why God had to appease God with any process of Atonement.

    When we are "saved" we are saved from GOD! (God's wrath comes from God, after all.)

    Jesus died to appease his own Father!

    Why do people paint a beautiful picture, or write a beautiful, sometimes heartbreaking song .....

    why are we moved by those things?

    Maybe I'm not understanding you

    re the other to share motivation

    unless you meant somethings else ...please explain

  • Terry
    Terry
    1.) It is repeated and stated on this thread that God is not real He is man made and so is His word the bible. Yet He is hated for those stories written by men in the name of a God - so why should these stories bother you if they aren't real.

    The world is driven mad and into madness by these man-made stories.

    If I could be left alone and outside the influence of those driven by odd myths of old I wouldn't be bothered. But, religion invades us all!

Share this

Google+
Pinterest
Reddit