Hi Kent: You asked, "Guests???? Since when were they guests? They came there after WWII, after a UN resolution, and they have not folowed one single demand or resolution from the UN since that."
The first time I heard the word 'Guest' was from a Palestinian co-worker in San Francisco. Another Palestinian friend in Oregon shared the book, The Dispora with me, which detailed the modern history of Jewish movement to Palestine and the problems encountered between the Jews and Muslims there. The book characterized the Jewish refugees as 'Guests' of Palestine. The Palestinian people had no problems with Jews or the Jewish faith. My Persian (Iranian) associates at work have made the same point.
What happened is that the Jews went from being 'Guests' who were allowed to settle there, to taking over. And through the decades, not only did many German Jews move there, but Russian and American Jews moved to what is now called Israel. That is where I got the term 'Guest' from listenining to Palestinians who grew up there and reading their literature. Another co-worker at bechtel in San Francisco was also a member of the PLO and came to the USA to complete his engineering degree, get some experience and then move back to Palestine. he too used that term 'Guest.' But, other than what I have been told by people I assume know their own history, I cannot say for sure.
You said, "Menachem Begin, I believe it was, was sentenced to death for terrorism by the Brits, but they couldn't execute a bigshot after Israel was founded."
Yep, I recall Menachem. I believe that he became PM there after Golda Meier died. I cannot dispute his acts, other than to say they he like Sharon and other Jewish leaders were considered freedom fighters. Palestinians obviously saw them as terrorists.
You said, "As for persecuting Jews - no nation can say they're innocent, I believe. Norway certainly not, neither any other western nation."
I have no specific information that would suggest the USA ever persecuted Jews. Like any ethnic group, there has been friction amnong Jews, Germans, Blacks, Irish, Italians, British, and about every other possible ethnicity that lives here. But that is not national or government sponsored persecution, that is just people problems - albeit, very serious.
You said, "In fact, the only nation that DID accept the Jews for a while were Germany! Believe it or not. But, for some reason or another, this goodwill changed, and Germany began thinking like the rest of the European countries."
Hitler was himself a half Jew, and an illigitmate child. If his mother (surnamed Hitler) had married Adolph's father, his last name would have been Schickelgrubber (sp). Hitler was responsible for raising the Jewish issue as a way to gain leverage among non-Jewish Germans. There are Neo-Nazi groups alive and well today in both Germany, the USA and many other countries that continue these hitler inspired myths about Jews.
You said, "(I can't say nothing about the view of Jews in the US, since I never read much about it, but my general impression from the little I did read was that it was pretty much the same all over the world)."
As I noted above, Jews have had problems in the USA as have many other ethnic groups, but there has never in our history been any sponsored persecution of Jews. Our nation enslaved African Americans, and were cruel and heavy-handed with Native Americans, and did house Japanese Americans in Internment campos during WWII, but never have the Jews here been treated that way. And Jews have enjoyed strong voting block, special civil rights protections, and they have powerful influence today in our Government. Senator Jow Lieberman, Democrat candidate for Vice President is a Jew. So Jews today enjoy high level visibility.
You noted, "Even though I know some people don't like me or my thoughts at all (and I don't care if they do), I feel it's important to be able to have more than one thought in the head at the same time."
just so you know, I like you and enjoy your comments. When some of your comments are crusty and maybe harsh, I try to ignore the passion and stcik with the issue. And you and I seem to do fine this way. I agree with you that it is vital to consider a number of views and examine evidence from various sources and try to arrive at fair and just opinions - and stay flexible so that as new information becomes available, we are able change as needed.
You said, "The fact that I'm crtisizing the US foreign policy isn't the same as I hate Americans. It's not the same as "bashing" anyone."
That's fair enough. Good point.
You said, "There IS a reason so many people hate Israel, and there IS a reason so many people hate the US. Personally I don't hate the US, and I don't hate the Americans either. But just because of that I would hope the foreign policy would change to a more modern one!"
I agree that the USA needs to make some significant changes in policy. That is why I appreciate President Bush's recent comment that he supports a Palestinian State - and did this even though is kind of irritated Israel.
You said, "Being the world police, bombing the head off anyone who doesn't agree can't work for ever. The military might can't protect anyone from everything. Suicide bombers can't be stopped by B52s or Tanks. No Carrier can help against Anthrax in letters - and even though there has been speculations on Irak being behind that, who knows if there isn't US citizens responsible?"
Americans became all too aware of our need not to be world police back during Viet Nam. That issue almost split our country apart. I recall the riots and outrage of Americans fighting the establishment over this issue. I myself stood trial before the Selective Service board and refused to join the Army. I was becoming a JW at the time, but I nevertheless shared on that side of the equation.
But, it is not that Americans want to be the world police. There are many 'hot spots' around the world where we have not gotten involved, and tried to mind our own business. But, the Persian Gulf War was a clear issue of both political, moral, and financial concern. And, I suspect that many nations, including Great Britain, France, and others shared our sentiments there as well ... judging from their men and equipment joining in with us. And this terrorists issue is not so much about being a police force for the planet as Americans feel their security threatened.
And if we cannot contain terrorist, we can make life hell for them, and, this time, what the terrorists must not have counted on is the nearly 100% national will supporting our government in attacking this issue with all resources, military, special ops, financial, political, etc. And, we will win this. I think this is a time in history where the average American is underestimated.
You said, "As I said, I don't hate the US, but many Americans hate the establishment. As far as I remember, one of these people were executed just a few months back - after killing a hell of a lot of people."
I don't feel hated. Especially not since 9-11 as many responsible and mature nations have rallied to our side. In fact, I have not felt so good about how we are being treated since the 1950s.
Yes, there as some few groups, some Neo-Nazi and some Conspiracy Theorists who have an axe to grind against the federal government. IN fact, some of these groups have been correct, and as a result won in court against the FBI for its handling of RUby Ridge case, both civil and criminal conbvictions were levied against the FBI. It was needed.
But then, people like Tim McVeigh took matters beyond peaceful means in the courts and used terror to attack the Federal Building in Oklahoma. He was executed for this, and I suported his execution, and would have been willing to be the execuitioner had I been asked. He is an evil bastard that deserved to die, as do the evil teroroists who attacked the World Trade Center.
You said, "So, every power has someone hating it, and that goes for the US as well. Israel is the biggest terrorist nation in the world, and should be a target in the War Against Terror!"
I agree that every nation has its friends, enemies, and shifting relationships. So, the USA understands this and can live with it. I am not convinced that Israel is a biggest terrorist nation in the world, but I agree that they do need to change, as does the USA and as should the PLO.
You said, "Let's see how honest the US government really is! They should target terrorism wherever it was, and target the government harbouring terrorists."
Good point! Perhaps this is a good time for our government to closely examine Israeli conduct and reconsider our relationship with Israel and perhaps demand that they cease such things and turn over their terrorists. Aside from their retaliations against the PLO, where else int he world have Israelis been terrorists?
You said, "Let's see what will happen to Israel - and what they will do to Syria now!"
Yes, I will be watching this too.
You said, "You see, Amazing - what so many people around the world hates is double talk and double standards. And even if seven006 don't enjoy the fact - arrogance and attacks on everyone who doesn't think the US equal God - won't help one bit."
I am not sure of the double talk and double standards that you have in mind. maybe we can exapnd on that in a separate thread.
You said, "As Seeker mentioned, the track record shows, unfortunately, the US has done many things many people really do have valid reasons for hating. Even seven006 would be pissed off if Samoa had killed his family and friends, one to three of them every year - and the rest of the world didn't give a damn about it."
I made some comments back to Seeker about this. But I must have missed the thing about Samoa.
But I am not convinced that I can agree that the USA has been doing a lot of bad. I think it is in what propaganda and spin room that affects a person's views that makes a lot of the difference. Just as the Bin Laden people use media and spin to lie about the USA to get more and more Islamic people hating us, and this eventually spills over into the opinion formation of others not affiliated with these radicals. Tell a lie often enough, long enough, and people start to believe it.
I understand that the USA is not perfect, but I am of the opinion that much of the hatred is from long held propaganda left over from the era of communism where we were lied against.
Hope that helps for now. I much enjoy your points and these exchanges. Thanks. - Amazing