A New Guy from Chicago with a Story to Tell

by Reborn2002 61 Replies latest jw experiences

  • VeniceIT
    VeniceIT

    HAhahah Comf I guess my point was I just don't see why we feel the need to get soooo involved in everyones life. He posted what he did I read it and can make my own decisions, but I don't feel the need personally to have the police report in my hand to decied if I'll talk to him. I mean who needs that really, are the posters on this board that important to you.

    I guess what I was trying to say Comf was do you care wether he slept with her or not??? do you disagree with pre-martial sex now??? I know you don't. He's still typing in a JW kinda way which makes everything seem crazy and insane. Did he rape her?? I don't know. if he did do you think he'd tell us No. So why get so involved in it?

    Let his posts let show what he is like, give it a bit of time. You don't have to like him, i just don't see why everyone has to be so judgmental and rude lately. there have been some other threads around that got real nasty for no reason other then some posters take themselves and this board WAY to seriously and were venting. I think that's sad and distrubing I just didn't want to see this thread head that way too. there's no need for it!!!

    Glad to you see your over it Comf, I'm not niave I don't just buy everything I read, but I do like to give people the benfit of the doubt and I don't feel the need to expose others flaws. I have plenty of my own and don't care to see them spread all over, so I guess I just give some people the kind of consideration I like, and fortuenlty have been able to enjoy on this board. Maybe because I am so honest, I guess I wear my heart on my sleave, and just wan't to be honest and help people and have a hell of a lot of fun in the process. I must say I'm impressed and pleased at how Prisca and Comf where able to resolve this thread to you both!!!

    Vennie

    "Injustice will continue until those who are not affected by it are as outraged as those who are."

  • BluesBrother
    BluesBrother

    Hello Jason

    Lets get back to the original post. Your story is so understandable to me.
    Elders. They ignore me too. I can get away with being a total non believer and never having to explain anything, why? because they never ask, no body cares, I like to think that, poor elder as I was, I would have tried to reach a fellow "brother" not doing anything bar come along to some meeting ,obviously just accompanying his wife.
    Pioneer Sisters. They are not always what they seem are they. I remember one in particular who both emotionally and phisically "screwed up" a friend of mine

    Take care, I hope this thread has encouraged you to keep posting. Believe me mate, we have all been there.

  • GatoCat
    GatoCat

    I guess what I was trying to say Comf was do you care wether he slept with her or not??? do you disagree with pre-martial sex now??? I know you don't.

    Do I care whether FredHall is really a JW or not?
    Do I care whether Prisca understands my words or not?
    Do I care whether AlanF is viewed as a god or an asshole or both?

    When I'm on this board, Vennie, it is the matters on this board that occupy my mind. I post here because I enjoy good repartee with people from backgrounds similar to mine. None of this stuff is of overriding importance to me; I have a wonderful life completely separate from jw.com. But when I'm here, the things that take place here are what I think about.

    Here's a new guy, telling a long, detailed story by way of introduction. The story doesn't hold together well. He obviously intends to stay here and be active with us, so I figure I'll ask him about those holes in his story. I do so in a calm, matter-of-fact manner with no insults. I'm careful to repeat over and over throughout the thread that I am not making any judgments, just asking for clarification.

    Did he rape her?? I don't know. if he did do you think he'd tell us No. So why get so involved in it?

    Because getting involved in it is what we do here. We talk, we exchange ideas and views, we fellowship. If this guy came up to a group of my fellow workers on the job, introduced himself as a new worker, and then offered something like this for us to consider, I would respond exactly as I have here on this board: by pointing out an inconsistency in what he said and asking for clarification.

    No, ultimately I don't care about what really happened at the girl's house. What I DO care about is whether somebody is bullshitting me and my friends or not--regardless of the topic. Because if he'll come in and introduce himself with a line of bullshit then you better believe, everything he says is going to be bullshit. You're content to wait a while and gradually figure out that you've been had. I'm not. When I see the signs, I ask about them right off. I can accept your apathy. Please accept my concern.

    I think you guys are just a little to shook up from the AlanF wars right now. You're reading my posts, but you're still hearing attitudes from all that. You need to realize that I am not attacking this guy in any way. I'm making conversation. I'm asking questions about what he posted. I'm trying to get a clearer picture on something that disturbed me in what he said.

    That's what we do, here, Vennie. We make conversation, and we comment on things others say and ask questions.

    I just didn't want to see this thread head that way too. there's no need for it!!!

    No problem. All he has to do is give good, reasonable, straight answers to my questions.

    I do like to give people the benfit of the doubt and I don't feel the need to expose others flaws.

    I give people the benefit of the doubt, too. I haven't come to any conclusions about him. I asked for an explanation.

    I guess I wear my heart on my sleave, and just wan't to be honest

    And do you expect honesty in return for your honesty?

    I must say I'm impressed and pleased at how Prisca and Comf where able to resolve this thread

    I am, too. It was a shocker, wasn't it. As I have stated before, I respond to people according to their choices. She could have chosen to prolong the head-butting and I would have kept on with her bout it. It was entirely in her hands, which way our discussion went, and she made a mature, insightful choice, much to my delight.

    Maybe Jason will, too, eh?

    COMF

  • Reborn2002
    Reborn2002

    Inconsistencies in my story? Granted, the only thing we have here on an online board to express our emotions or feelings is words, but for you to question my honesty so blatantly I feel warrants a defensive streak. Especially considering all Ive been put through I dont need someone who doesnt even know me accusing me based on semantics when all I did was type from the heart, I apologize if I didnt take the time to make it novelesque for you to be completely satisfied with grammar.

    I was accused of something I did not do. I was questioned by a band of brothers in a committee at a congregation I had just transferred to about something I did not do. I confirmed that I spent the night there, but when it became interrogated about sexual matters which never took place because she wanted to make it look like I forced myself upon her, that was way past any line of decency.

    Whats so inconsistent about the truth? If you have any questions whatsoever feel free to ask me specifically, I have no reason to come onto an online board and lie to complete strangers about the unfortunate events in my life. I just needed to vent my frustration, not having any friends virtually because the organization didnt allow comraderie with "worldly" folk, then leaving that behind as well makes one seem pretty alone, so I wanted somewhere to talk. It seems your trying to sit and psychoanalyze every single word I type and if all your going to do is question my integrity, I ask you to leave me alone. Ive had enough BS in my life, I dont need more from you. If you want to be comforting or share the common interest in believing that there are serious issues in the world which need addressing, then by all means Im up for chat.

    The true Kingdom of God is located in your heart, not an organization of hypocrites.

    www.geocities.com/latinloverchicago/Jason1.html for my new webpage and info!! Im trying to live now!!

  • COMF
    COMF

    Maybe Jason will, too, eh?

    Or not...

  • sweetone2377
    sweetone2377

    Jason,

    Welcome. I'm sure that you will find support, encouragement, and love here. The people on this board have been a wonderful shoulder for me and I'm sure they will do the same for you. Keep your head held high and know that you are no longer a prisioner. Freedom is scarey for all at first, but all works itself out to the good in the end. Good luck!

    Shelly
    Former victim and recovering wonderfully from a broken spirit
    Smile, because we all have been freed from slavery!!

  • GatoCat
    GatoCat

    for you to question my honesty so blatantly I feel warrants a defensive streak.

    I haven't questioned your honesty. I said that your story had inconsistencies in it, which it does; I've mentioned them in previous posts, and obviously you have read those posts, so you know what they are. I asked you to explain them, which you have not done.

    I dont need someone who doesnt even know me accusing me

    I haven't accused you of anything, as I have stated repeatedly from post to post. You're kind of slow on the pickup, aren't you.

    I apologize if I didnt take the time to make it novelesque for you to be completely satisfied with grammar.

    I haven't said a word about grammar. You're trying to make my questions look petty. They are not about grammar, and they are not petty.

    If you have any questions whatsoever feel free to ask me specifically

    Please explain how the elders came to be asking the question, "Did she resist?" Resist what?
    Please explain what they meant when they said, "Was it porneia?" Was what porneia?
    Please explain how her saying you attempted to rape her would explain you spending the night at her house.

    It seems your trying to sit and psychoanalyze every single word I type

    No it doesn't. You're just exaggerating. Why don't you just explain clearly and be done with it instead of doing all this flipping and flopping?

    and if all your going to do is question my integrity, I ask you to leave me alone.

    I haven't questioned your integrity, although your continued avoidance of the points I've raised is starting to make it look questionable all by itself.

    Ive had enough BS in my life, I dont need more from you.

    You haven't gotten any BS from me. I asked you about some inconsistencies in your story. That's all. Are you having trouble explaining them?

    COMF

  • COMF
    COMF

    Okay, then, let's take them one at a time.

    If you have any questions whatsoever feel free to ask me specifically

    Please explain how the elders came to be asking the question, "Did she resist?" Resist what?

    COMF

  • Reborn2002
    Reborn2002

    For the sake of discussion COMF, you strike me as the type of a$$hole that if someone was just mugged, your first reaction in talking to them would be to see how many holes you can punch in their story to see if they made it up for an insurance scam.

    Lets be honest, to continue to press the issue of someone having inconsistencies is to question their honesty. To call me slow on the pickup is also an indirect insult thrust in my direction. Your about the most impolite person Ive ever encountered online.

    Ok, now.. to be more specific.

    The elders and others already knew we were 'talking' because she had visited my congregation and I had visited hers on a few occasions. She lives in an apartment with her two older sisters, age 20 and 21. Her older sister was also dating my friend at the time, so often we would go visit together and double date because it was more fun in groups and it is also encouraged to be in groups. So yes, it is 3 girls in an apartment. Her family nor anyone else knew that I and my friend had spent the night on a few occasions with their invite, and that even on a few occasions I spent the night by myself with her on her invite. We just enjoyed one anothers company and it was a 90minute drive home for me, so often I would stay.

    Now, when her mother found out that I had spent the night, she made the story up that we had been drinking, that I slept in her bed with her, and forced myself upon her. What other reason would she make this up other than to make herself look like being a Pioneer she would NEVER allow a man to spend the night with her? To save face.

    Her mother gave her the ultimatum that either she would go to the elders about it, or that her mother would. I learned this from her older sister. Then she told her elders this story as soon as possible, and I knew nothing of it. I had just went home thinking all was as usual.

    When I had called her two days later she even had the audacity to lie to me on the phone and tell me that her friend was in a car accident and she would be out of town. I believed it at the time hook-line-and-sinker, but little did I know it was an all-out-lie so she could avoid me until the elders had their way with me. I didnt learn about this until later, when I angrily confronted her and her family and brought this accident up, when her mother said "what accident?" but somehow justified a blatant lie because it was the elders who told her to avoid me.

    So I went to my meeting. Sitting in the audience as usual, most of you know how it goes. Tapped on the shoulder, "your wanted in the back". Not expecting anything bad, I walk to the back pretty casually.
    When I walk in 3 elders are sitting there. This is where it got ugly, I personally believe your guilty until proven innocent, and that the perspective is not only skewed to the person who goes blabbing first, but also to a woman. Ever notice how so often the woman gets reproved or nothing, and the guy gets DF'd?

    Paraphrasing what was said because Ill never forget that night.
    "Have a seat"
    "Its come to our attention some inappropriate events have taken place between you and Celeste (her name) anything you wanna tell us about?"

    Dumbfounded I said no not particularly.

    "Is it true that youve been spending the night there rather frequently?" Now consider they werent interested in the fact that she had invited me to spend the night, that she WANTED me to spend the night, that she allowed me to spend the night, only that I was in fact there.

    I was honest, I said yes I had.

    I am 21, she is underage to be drinking.
    "Is it true that you drank alcoholic beverages while there?"
    Honest, yes we did.

    "Did you or her get drunk" (drunkenness is also a grounds for DF)
    No, I did not get drunk, she got pretty buzzed though.

    Did you sleep in the same room as her?
    "Yes I slept in the same bed, we often did, its better than sleeping on the floor, besides she invited me to sleep in her bed!" (This was the case every time I spent the night there. I always slept in the bed, I wasnt gonna sleep on the hardwood floor)

    Then COMF, is when it got to the part you sought clarification on, and when these questions hit, it thunderstruck me. Resoundingly untrue, but they kept asking very specific questions, with seemingly no regard for my emotions.

    "Did you force yourself upon her?" NO

    Even after I said no, they had already received confirmation from me that I was in the same bed and she was buzzed, so like friggin police detectives they asked

    Did she resist you? Did you touch her private parts? You know thats porneia dont you? Did you commit porneia?"

    NO, NO, NO, NO.

    Well her body of elders has contacted us and informed us she states you took advantage of her while there. That she tried to resist you, and that being a pioneer she would never allow herself to commit something like that.

    ---

    To anyone reading, is it more clear now why I am angry? And is this perhaps a little more detailed so as to provide clarification for your inquiries? COMF, Im sure youll find some inconsistency here, lawyers work wonders in twisting the truth so that it fits their agenda. I dont have reason to sit here and fabricate anything on an online board. I came across this website with the intent of at least talking and venting, not having my integrity questioned. Like it or not, your statements have questioned my integrity. I fully expect you to reply with some sarcastic remark or glaring inconsistency youve uncovered. Your a pretty rude guy you know that. If someone was indeed a victim of being lied about, used, abused, or something of the sort, your the kind when they are just pouring out their heart telling their story, your more interested in intricate details and inconsistencies, often making them feel as if you are somehow blaming them; when they are just venting, in need of encouragement or acknowledgment, and you provide just the opposite.

    So I say to you, if you are indeed going to reply to this post, and I know that you will.. you strike me as the type who likes the last word and to feel important, either say something kind and encouraging, or say nothing at all. If you sit here and try to poke inconsistencies in what Ive said, I will just ignore you from this point forward. That clear enough for you? If your indeed capable of saying something kind. I have no problem being thorough and telling what happened, in fact I feel a little better just typing it away and posting it for the world to see, its out there and not building up in my stomach ya know? But I wont tolerate being insulted (slow on the pickup) nor having my integrity questioned (make it look questionable all by itself)

    So COMF, over the last few months of things Ive tolerated, I say this. Say something nice, or shut the hell up. Any further instigating or rude remarks from you will be disregarded.

    The true Kingdom of God is located in your heart, not an organization of hypocrites.

    www.geocities.com/latinloverchicago/Jason1.html for my new webpage and info!! Im trying to live now!!

  • YoYoMama
    YoYoMama

    Reborn: I see nothing wrong with the questions the three elders asked you. I mean here is a young girl saying she was raped. What are the elders to do? Of course they have to investigate to see if it's true or not. Rape is a serious crime. And what questions where they going to ask? You're telling them that you slept with her in her bed. The next logical questions are the ones they asked. By the way you are reacting, it makes your story a bit fishy. I'm not saying your guilty, it just sounds fishy.

    Now you say that you DA'ed yourself. So what was the outcome of the judicial committee? If you were not disfellowshipped, the elders must have believed what you testified to.

Share this

Google+
Pinterest
Reddit