Christian Apologists - Please Watch This and Tell Us Why it is wrong?

by cantleave 834 Replies latest watchtower beliefs

  • sabastious
    sabastious
    We can't say that burning witches is wrong, but we can call me evil and a criminal? Or is burning witches wrong, but it didn't used to be, it used to be good. And since god=good, and the definition of good changes over time, does this mean that god changes. This was actually a question I already asked, but you skipped it. If it is evil to burn witches (and I think it is) then has Satan changed? Satan = Evil, but it used to be good to burn witches (of god) and now it is evil (of satan). My head hurts.

    Right and wrong are progressive, Good and Evil and finite. Why is that so obvious to me, but so many people think I am crazy?

    -Sab

  • sabastious
    sabastious
    Do you understand the scientific method? No checks and balances? Do we live on the same earth?

    Apparently not, you worship a method and I my creator.

    -Sab

  • cantleave
    cantleave

    Sab, the scientific community is far from corrupt! The methodolgies employed in research are are highly unbiased. The truth is there is simply no evidence for god!

  • sabastious
    sabastious
    To the idea of fighting against truth being evil... this fighting could simply be ignorance, and we are all guilty of that in some shape or form. Someone would have to know the truth, and fight against it and those who abide by it, in order to perhaps be considered evil.

    Exactly, it could be a result of ignorance and then it would not be evil. Evil is purposeful and with all known factors considered.

    -Sab

  • bohm
    bohm

    Sab: Would you have stood up for the sorcerers right to live if you lived back then?

    No, because i would likely belong to a dumbass retard religion which had convinced me that ol' Mashebeth should be stoned to death since Josephs cow died.

    I cant wait to hear where this profound insight on what i would have done 3000 years ago will lead you!

    You'd likely pick up a pitch fork and join the mob just to make sure no one knows the truth about your secret morals. Hind sight is 20/20, a perfect world only exists off the vindicated deaths of the innocent. Can you give me an example of when science was invented in a world where sorcerer's were not brualized at some point?

    I can give you an even better example. In the western world we have discovered there is no such thing as witches so we do not burn witches anymore. Scientific scrutiny and the demand for evidence had a large role to play in that if you read the witch trials.

    Now we DO actually have places in africa where young girls are regularily branded as witches and killed all in the name of Jesus and no doubt using exodus as the textbook; Would it be a crime, evil and a hinderence of progress to explain to these people how wrong those ideas are? to use logic and evidence to demonstrate the wrongness of their ideas?

    Because it sure is hard to pick up the bible (and whatever tribal crap they have mixed into their religion) and demonstrate satan cant posess people and there is no such thing as witchcraft, but it is an entirely trivial thing to do with the scientific method.

  • NewChapter
    NewChapter

    Right and wrong are progressive, Good and Evil and finite. Why is that so obvious to me, but so many people think I am crazy?

    So simple question. Was burning witches good or evil (like me)?

    More complicated question: What relationship does good and evil have with right and wrong?

    NC

  • sabastious
    sabastious
    Sab, the scientific community is far from corrupt! The methodolgies employed in research are are highly unbiased. The truth is there is simply no evidence for god!

    The community is very corrupt, the method isn't. Just like the Bible is fine, but it's community is corrupt. Just like the US Constitution is fine, but it's community is corrupt. It's a human pattern.

    -Sab

  • NewChapter
    NewChapter

    The community is very corrupt, the method isn't

    Do you have evidence for this? It's a big charge.

    Just like the US Constitution is fine, but it's community is corrupt.

    Based on what? Whether you agree or not?

    Just like the Bible is fine, but it's community is corrupt

    Have you READ the bible?

  • sabastious
    sabastious
    So simple question. Was burning witches good or evil (like me)?

    Burning witches was a byproduct of an evil culture which is extremely complex. It's not a simple question at all. Remember those logical traps I spoke about? Yeah, you just did it. You can't just pull something like burning witches out of a hat and demand answers, that's a childish argument. You must paint the entire anthropoligical picture and then decide what's what and who did what. I'm not interested in being trapped.

    -Sab

  • poopsiecakes
    poopsiecakes

    Lord love a duck this thread is a mess.

    Sab, I just started a new job and work with a woman who wears a hijab (look it up if you don't know what it is). I don't know her very well yet because I just started this job but she very candidly told me that she had some health problems a few months ago and started wearing it again because of how important it is to God. Does your god reason the same way? If not, why not?

Share this

Google+
Pinterest
Reddit