has anyone ever tried to match the JW figures against what is reported for the last census in countries like USA, UK, AU, CA using the closest year book ? Do the figures match ?
Hi mP, good question.
Over the years, I have compared the reported publisher-numbers in New Zealand with the official NZ census figures. While there is a downward trend in the census numbers identifying themselves and their minor children as JWs, census figures are a good 30 to 40% higher than the reported publisher figures. So the Watchtower cannot on that basis be 'accused' of inflating publisher numbers.
I do not have the figures on hand at present (I am posting from a business site away from home), but the approximate numbers during our last census (1996) were as follows:
There were about 12,500 publishers in New Zealand compared with a census figure of about 17,000 self- and child-identified JWs. Keep in mind the census asks parents to complete forms for their minor children and the religious affiliation question does not ask if you are an active member of a religion but asks you to name the religion you are affiliated with. With such a broad question, it is no surprise that far more people identify themselves and their minor children as affiliated with the JWs than are currently active as publishers. It obviously includes inactive JWs, those who have more or less left but who continue to identify as JWs, etc. It probably also includes (some) disfellowshipped JWs because we all know of people who are booted out but keep trying to come back (but that's a different topic!)
BTW, in an earlier census (2001) close to 20,000 were identified as JWs compared to 17,000 in 1996 - hence there is definite decrease in numbers self-identifying as JWs.
New Zealand was due to have a census last year (2011) but it was canceled in the immediate wake of the devastating Christchurch city earthquake - so we will have to wait for a longer time before up-to-date comparisons between Watchtower figures and Census figures can be provided.