Why should god value a person's ability to assent to unlikely ideas?
Heh, I'm not sure. But let's not assume that God doesn't value "kindness or compassion or loyalty", it needn't be a case of "one or the other". As a Witness, I believed that God valued faith because at the time of ancient Israel, no one questioned his existence. "Faith" meant "trust in the power of God". Only in modern times has Satan decided to make things more difficult by hiding God using the so-called "age of reason". Now faith is more difficult to have than it used to be, but if we appreciate God's values enough, then we will persist in believing in and worshipping him. Or something like that. Sounds kind of strained, doesn't it?