Tim

by teejay 44 Replies latest jw friends

  • SixofNine
    SixofNine

    mommy,

    What is it that seperates some of us from going over the edge? What makes some of us murder and others not? Can you honestly say you will never be in a predicament where you will not cross the line?

    And what happens on that day you cross the line? Should we all just spit you out as evil and unworthy of life? Come on...you are still SixofNine.


    I think I can honestly say that I can't imagine a predicament where I would cross the line. If I ever do, I would hope that my viewpoints would not change based on my own selfish need to absolve myself. I think the greatest thing in the world would be for all humans to agree that anyone can murder anyone else, so long as we all know and agree in advance that said murder equals suicide for the murderer.

    So if I ever cross that line, I hope you will remember my more friendly post. And you can have my cat. Patio gets my bible, Teejay gets my UT penant, and crossroads gets my spirit (dont' forget to bring a spirit-catcher to witness the execution)

    teejay,

    … or so goes the claim of the conquerors, who always write the history books.

    Actually, that is my claim based on things I heard Koresh say, and things I watched him do, both before and during the stand off. I can hardly be considered a 'conqueror'.

  • mommy
    mommy

    Six,
    LOL I have 14 cats now! I would rather have your spirit

    I think I can honestly say that I can't imagine a predicament where I would cross the line. If I ever do, I would hope that my viewpoints would not change based on my own selfish need to absolve myself,


    I really admire that you can honestly say that. I can't. Have you ever done anything you are sorry about later? I have. Have you ever heard of rage? I have.
    wendy

  • teejay
    teejay

    >> Here is some advice, take it or leave it. You want to talk about
    >>government conspiracies around the campfire? Go find yourself a real one,
    >>I'm sure there are a few. But if you find yourself "taking up"for a christ
    >>complexed demigod child molester and Jim Jones wannabe … don't be
    >>surprised if many people think you are on the wrong track. In fact, don't be
    >>too surprised if your 'take' on the matter leaves some of us a bit angry and
    >>sick to our stomach.

    Six,

    Relax, Bro! I'm not even trying to defend either Koresh or McVeigh,
    only people's response to them and, in the larger picture, God's lack of
    response to these and other, more horrendous events.

    Look… the first was a wacko who, as you pointed out, was very delusional,
    as were his followers or else they would've known better. The ones who
    suffered most were the kids. The second had delusions of his own that sprang
    from legitimate concerns -- he saw himself as a modern-day Patrick Henry or
    Samuel Adams, a patriot compelled to do SOMETHING for the sake of all of
    the powerless Americans who were being misused by the government that had
    lost its course. Make no mistake about it, Six, I defend neither of them. As I said,
    the air will be a tad sweeter when McVeigh is gone.

    >>Sorry, I didn't really get that from your original post. Did you mean
    >>"pointing to a lack of any real evidence..."?

    That's EXACTLY what I meant. Corrections have been made.

    >>Although I have been wondering if perhaps it may not be within His power
    >>to just snap his fingers and make everything peachy.

    Bingo! If he's aware at all!!

    Reminds me of the time recorded in the Good Book when I-Forget-Who
    challenged the local Baals and when they failed the test, Yahweh's prophet
    made the claim that maybe the local Baal gods were in the privy. Based on
    human history, I'd say the same accusation could be made of the One True
    God.

    peace,
    todd

  • teejay
    teejay

    patio34,

    >>I'm offering my nascent views: there is no supernatural being in charge of
    >>everything … It is up to humans to administer justice … it is pointless to
    >>lament the lack of action of a mythical being … Once humans accept there
    >>is no magical being to solve the problems, they can be liberated from an
    >>anachronistic belief and get to work!

    While I have not yet reached the comfortable place of saying WITH CERTAINTY
    that there is no God, I'm headed in that direction, basing my opinion on the
    tangible evidence.

    Have you seen the movie The Bodyguard (Kevin Costner and Whitney
    Houston)? It was entertaining, I guess, but the final scene made the viewing
    very worthwhile for me at the time. At the beginning of some sort of
    conference a prayer is being offered for God's protection. As usual there is
    no evidence that the one meant to receive the prayer even hears. Yet, in the
    background is the bodyguard, hired to protect one of the attendees. While every
    ones else bows their heads in humble posture, he is wide-eyed and vigilant,
    watching, ready to act on behalf of his client. Because of HUMAN
    involvement, if anything does go down, we don't expect to hear that the
    carnage was simply "god's will." The client will be protected (as much as
    humanly possible) because someone, someBODY, is on the job.

    I extended the moral of that scene to other human endeavors (medicine,
    science, government, etc), and I agree with you:

    Once humans accept there is no magical being to solve the problems, they
    can be liberated from an anachronistic belief and get to work!

    Well said! Carefully read the last sentence in my original post. We are in agreement.

    peace,
    todd

  • teejay
    teejay

    SixofNine,

    So if I ever cross that line, I hope you will remember my more friendly
    post. And you can have my cat. Patio gets my bible, Teejay gets my UT
    penant, and crossroads gets my spirit…

    Does that mean what I think it means? "UT" = University of Texas?
    yecccchh!!!

    I'm a Razorback at heart, so, I appreciate your offer but you can keep your
    pukey, little burnt orange penant, thank you very much. I like Razorback
    Red much better! :)

    >>Actually, that is my claim based on things I heard Koresh say, and things I
    >>watched him do, both before and during the stand off. I can hardly be
    >>considered a 'conqueror'.

    No, you're not the conqueror I was referring to. However, unless you were
    there, in person, with Koresh and his group, what you heard him say and saw
    him do was a product of the true history-makers whose mission was and is
    always meant to convince the public that their actions are right, appropriate
    and correct. Even after the fact, exculpatory statements from every conceivable
    corner of the gov't have been made in abundance: "We were right and totally
    justified in what we did. They were totally wrong and got what they deserved…
    oh… uh… sorry for the kids, though… but it's all HIS fault…"

    Why expect anything different? The conquerors are never evil, never wrong,
    never unconstitutional. The American government's actions are always right,
    right? Always above reproach. Even when calling Iraqi infants "collateral damage."
    The breaking story of former Senator Kerrey's involvement with atrocities
    committed on innocent Vietnamese women and children, at the behest
    of military commanders
    , shouldn't shock anyone.

    My country, right or wrong. Right? Wrong.

    peace
    todd
    ___________________________________________________
    If you believe everything you read, better not read.
    -------------- Japanese Proverb

    (paraphrasing: if you believe everything you see on TV,
    you probably shouldn't watch TV)

  • crossroads
    crossroads

    Six-Thanks for your spirit , wendy I'll share a little of
    it with you but you can keep the cat.

    A good discusion was had.
    Give me King, Ghandi, Jesus himself now there's a
    peaceful revolution for you.
    I agree that it is up to US to stop the horrors not God.
    He gave us this peaceful place-We chose not to be.
    "You may say I'm a dreamer but I'm not the only one
    I hope someday you'll join US and the world will live
    as ONE.

  • crossroads
    crossroads

    Oh six I forgot one thing. It will show you I too am
    human.I have a line no one must cross. If someone
    where to molest my liitle boy-vengance would be
    mine-I would do it in front of all on lookers-I would
    pay any price for my act-willing.

    It seems TIM had a different line-He is willing paying
    the price is he not?

  • SixofNine
    SixofNine

    Teejay, from that last post, I kinda get a sense that you might be someone who has had an epiphany that the government is not to be trusted, and of course we all know the news media often gets it wrong, so, someone comes along and points this out, and you go so far the other way that everything is a conspiracy, nothing we hear in the news media is correct, etc, etc. IMO, the folks who I see taking that stance, and writing and SELLING books to take that stance, are often idiots. You don't seem to be an idiot. In fact, as wasa said, your command of our language and writing style is impressive indeed.

    If you're going to be a skeptic (and I highly recommend it), please be a equal opportunity skeptic.

    I am well aware of the maxim about conquerors getting to write history. My point was that I can certainly filter what the government says about it's actions along with all the sources of info I get. In Koresh's case, that info was often gotten by seeing his face and his voice, or hearing either his followers, or family members of his followers. So my information is, to a large extent, a product of no history maker other than the principles involved.

    If Tim McVeigh had been as skeptical of the single toothed gub'ment conspiratoralist as he was of the gub'ment, he would not have felt the misplaced rage that he felt.

    I can't think of any logic which would make me think that any of the individuals involved at Waco, other than David Koresh and a handful of his adult followers, would possibly have wanted anything but the most peaceful outcome. Feel free to give me some fresh ideas on that.

    ps. about UT, I was trapped in a cult which strongly discouraged higher education, so I did not go to any college. I could tell from your post that you lived in OK, so I just thought I would raz you a bit.

    Once humans accept there is no magical being to solve the problems, they
    can be liberated from an anachronistic belief and get to work!

    patio, let me join teejay in applauding that statement. I'm still not sure (and may never be) about the existence of a creator or not, but I am with you that there will be no magical problem solving forthcoming! So let's get to work.

  • SixofNine
    SixofNine

    Crossroads, glad to see you're human. I feel much the same about my daughter. But, I think, I hope, that even in our rage, given even a few minutes to think about it, you and I both would only end up taking action that would be in the best interest of our children.

    But really, no need to compare your line with Tim's. It's the difference between good and evil, human and feces.

  • teejay
    teejay

    Six,

    >>you go so far the other way that everything is a conspiracy,
    >>nothing we hear in the news media is correct, etc, etc. IMO, the folks
    >>who I see taking that stance, and writing and SELLING books to take
    >>that stance, are often idiots… If you're going to be a skeptic please be
    >>a equal opportunity skeptic … I can certainly filter what the government
    >>says about it's actions along with all the sources of info I get. In Koresh's
    >>case, that info was often gotten by seeing his face and his voice, or
    >>hearing either his followers, or family members of his followers. So my
    >>information is, to a large extent, a product of no history maker other than
    >>the principles involved.

    I never said that everything is a conspiracy. Come on, Six.. play fair!!
    I really believe that we are not far from having the very same opinion, both of
    Koresh and McVeigh, only in relative degree of evil, if it could be measured on
    a scale somehow. I'm not a major conspiracy theorist, per se, (I did read The
    Unseen Hand
    , though) but I do believe that certain things aren't at all like they
    are played up to be in the media. I don't see conspiracies nightly on the national
    news or CNN, but I DO happen to believe that every now and then the aims of the
    powerful and super-wealthy don't jibe with those of common folk like me and you
    and they use their influence to get a certain message across that isn't entirely
    harmonious with all of the facts, known or unknown.

    Like you, I believe that most of the Davidians, if not every single one (including
    Koresh) simply wanted to be left alone to worship their god as they saw fit.
    While I have the opinion that Koresh did indeed want to push the ATF as to
    his Constitutional rights in the matter of the weapons he had stockpiled (which
    the ATF asserted he had no right to at all), I really don't think he was suicidal,
    except maybe at the very end. But maybe not even then. I could be wrong, though.

    Perhaps he was consumed by his God-complex, but who can say with
    absolute certainty? Visuals on a TV screen can be misread, just as words on a
    pc monitor can as well as body language on the part of someone in whose
    actual presence we may be. Misunderstandings occur, later resolved with a
    simple, "Oh, I'm sorry. I didn't know… I misunderstood." It's my contention
    that, in the case of Koresh, we will never know with certainty. We'll never
    have our present view of him clarified by increased understanding, especially
    since the only exposure we got to him was through the filter of a government
    agency that has had problems with candor before and since. The complete
    story of why a small handful of bible thumpers in the rolling hill country of
    south-central Texas were deemed such a threat that the full weight of the U.S.
    government felt compelled to intervene to the extent it did will probably never
    be known.

    Be that as it may, all of that is somewhat peripheral to my original post which
    I admit could've been clearer as to its intent. Let's make a leap and say that
    both Koresh and McVeigh are the two vilest humans ever to walk the earth. Hell,
    throw Genghis Khan, Hitler, Mussolini, Pol Pot, Khadafi and whoever else into the
    mix, I don't care, and the guilt they collectively bear for their horrific crimes does
    nothing to absolve "God" of his inattentiveness and inaction respective of human
    misery and suffering, especially since, as I was taught, Jehovah supposedly has
    had all the legal ammo he's needed to bring the suffering to an end for more than
    two millennia.

    The platitudes of religionists (JWs included) that all the evil is just a part of some
    Grand Scheme and that at some future time of his design he'll make things all rosy
    rings more and more hollow the longer I live. On that I'm thinking you and I are
    in full agreement. If I've ever had an epiphany, that's the one I had that day when
    that nice Christian lady told me that God loves us while we were overshadowed by
    a nine-story office building with its northern face ripped off, where 168 innocent
    people spent their last seconds of life, all while "God" watched. The hell he does!

    >>about UT, I was trapped in a cult which strongly discouraged higher education,
    >>so I did not go to any college. I could tell from your post that you lived in OK, so
    >>I just thought I would raz you a bit.

    HA! They never said you couldn't go to college....

    Seems we were trapped in the same cult, though I'm taking some classes
    now. As far as the "UT" reference, I figured you were just trying to get my goat.
    Yet I wanted to make it clear that I ain't no Okie. As my man Barney Fife on
    The Andy Griffith Show would say, I wanted to "Nip it, nip it, nip it in the bud."

    later, dude, and peace!
    todd

Share this

Google+
Pinterest
Reddit