Man my heart sinks for you.... I can tell you his side of the story first hand.. I dated outside the truth with a girl for 4 years and what a stress. Please bare with me as I want to cover soooo many point and do not want to make this a novel.
- If you guys do get married what are you ok that the kids will have no christmas or other worldy holidays. I am sure if you have been dating him you know that it is hard during these times. I am sure you even talked about it, but imagine how hard it would be to celebrate with your kids while dad sat in the corner and did nothing. Plus this would cause so much stress for him because the local elders would be like all over him and what happends in his house is a direct reflection on his standing with Jehovah.
- When I was dating this girl I always assumed if I dealt with it slowl she would just come to the meetings eventually. I asked her to come to special talks, memorials and etc hoping that she would just convert. Maybe he is doing the same thing. Maybe he is hoping that you just convert. Now I am not a JW hater at all, but if the religion is something that you know you will not be happy with then stand your grounf firm and do not change. That is so loving of you to accept his faith it is only fair that he accepts yours. The thing is JW culture is not accepting at all of different faiths and you will never have full approval of his close friends or family.
- What would happend if you kid was in accident and needed blood? What would happend?
- As much as you think you know what pressure he is under, you have no idea. There is no doubt he loves you but I am sure his heart is so torn. His family is telling him one thing, which they think is right because I am sure they do not want to see you get hurt or him, but it is RARE these relatioships work. Trust me you bf is in complete turmoil. If he is on the fence he does not want to let god down, but realizes he has to compromise to make things work with the girl he loves. Plus after 4 years I assume you guys have done more then hold hands and I sure that tears him up inside too.
- I am sorry this f-ing sucks soo bad. If JW could just have a little compromise in their belives you ca make this work. The best advice I have is lay is ALL on the table. Tell him that you will not become a witness for him (if you really do not want to) and this is what you can accept if the relationship is to continue. Make sure to talk about where you will getr married, kids, everything be brutally honest with him and be honest with yourself. You are at a hue risk of losing him and I am sure in your mind is somethin you can not even think about life without him, but I am sorry hun you have to think with reason on this one.
- You mention he is distancing himself. He very well could be. This is a total assumption, but I am sure he loves you and he does not want to break up but in his mind if he draws away from you, you will break up and he will not have to do it himself making the out easier you kow. Call him on this and see if that is the case.
- Just being brutally honest these relationships will NOT work in most cases. My mom/dad are different in religious views (dad is a JW mom is not) and have seen it work, but my mom is SOOOOOO compromising it is unreal. If you are that type of person great, but to be honest life is to short for you not to be totally happy.
Aww damn it my heart goes out to you soooo much... Please ask me anything at anytime. I pray that this works out for you both. Keep us posted.