Posts by JWdaughter

32

The hypocrisy Jesus had towards the pharisees and sadducees

by adjusted knowledge in

jw
friends

it is no wonder the jewish leaders had ridiculous rules concerning the sabbath.

the following scripture alone should instill fear of those forsaking the sabbath.. (numbers 15:32-36)--"now while the sons of israel were in the wilderness, they found a man gathering wood on the sabbath day.

33and those who found him gathering wood brought him to moses and aaron, and to all the congregation; 34and they put him in custody because it had not been declared what should be done to him.

JWdaughter

The wandering around just muching grains argument may be fair enough (or not, but whatever), but the first thing that went through my mind was, so THOSE grains didn't count against you for the sabbath like all calories don't count (if you are driving, on your birthday, if you are drunk, or while you are cooking). It strikes me initially with it being a distinction without much of a difference. Gathering grains to eat is what you do during the harvest, too. I imagine some of them are "munched", too.

I continually wonder about the rules that matter to God (assuming you believe there is one and there was ever any truth to scriptures) vs. the things that man came up with over time to "clarify" his rules (like the blood transfusion teaching and the prohibition against smoking)

How much of what made it to the works we now count as scripture were actually "inspired"? Considering the history of its being written, I would submit that there is plenty that was "cleared up" the priests and teachers as they were gathering their followers and encouraging them to 'righteousness'.

15

Story of a GB ass-kisser

by zound in

jw
friends

i was reading a life story article in the latest watchtower and had a few thoughts about it i thought i'd share here.

these life story things are always so depressing to me - this one is slightly interesting because it is told by a current "governing body helper".. it's called "full time ministry - where it has led me.

" reading it i just got the impression that this guy (robert) was aiming to be a gb member but fell short and ended up being a gb "helper".

JWdaughter

It's a pretty sad life story. It does not seem like a spiritual paradise, but I never really got a lot out of brown nosing. Doesn't suit my temperment. The thing is, that DOES suit the temperments of a lot of people in this world. If he found a place that works for him-well. Good for him. Lucky he never got sent home when he was 55 like many do.

39

My sister was invited to a Judicial Committee

by opusdei1972 in

today i called to my sister and she told me that two elders went to her house to announce her that a judicial committe is waiting her in the kingdom hall this friday.

she told them that she will confirm if she will go.

however, i have told her that she shouldn't go, instead she should ask them to write a formal letter, with signatures, asking her for which charges she should be submitted in a private room with two men (or three?

JWdaughter

There are legal service plans that are $20 a month. They will,for that $20, consult with you and write a letter for you. Cheaper than hiring a lawyer the old fashioned way. If you need a follow up, then they will charge (discounted from normal letter writing charge). They are good for other things too-so you could get your families wills drawn up, a med. power of attorney (to make sure JW relative doesn't get power over you if ill) and consult about a lot of things for no hourly charge. Having a lawyer gives you power to get your right to not be harrassed by these idiots. One of the mottos is that they help you in all legal matters-trivial to tragic. Isnt it ironic that our dealings with the WT are both those things?. It is really all this trivial CRAP that often ends up being a tragedy to families as they are destroyed by their association with this organization.

46

JW TV is the reason for the hysteria in the KH

by campaign of hate in

jw
friends

if you, like me, have noticed the sudden increase in hysteria in the khs right now, i put it down to that jw tv site.

its's far more extensive than i thought it was, i thought it was just 1, 1 hour program a month.

there's a s*** load of videos on that site.. and the real problem, from just watching a clip from each video, is that these guys are clearly "mentally unstable".

JWdaughter

Hey, if they go all batsh** crazy, just short of Jonestown, they still get what they want. They have all these properties and over the next few years seem to be on a building boom(by their accounts) that will be accomplished with as much donated land, materials and labor as they can squeeze out of folks, they are preparing JWs to fully expect to be meeting in basements wearing JEANS, no less(!), they want your money, they demand obedience, the ask you to do dumb ass things (not logical to normal human beings). So a bunch of people drop out. The leavers have no recourse to keep or sell the buildings so they are SOL. The org consolidates the congregations over the next few years and sells hall after hall after hall. At some point, they create a crisis point and convince all JWs they are being persecuted(or they might be persecuted-who knows what kind of crap the WT will pull to accomplish it?). The last few halls head for the basements. They decide that halls are superfluous and gradually (as the economy dictates the best timing) sell off all the halls. They won't have many JWs left, but the residual wealth will keep chosen ones in luxury and comfort for generations to come without another donation to speak of. In the meantime, the elders will move/disappear and records will vanish and make it difficult to prosecute congregations that no longer exist. Brothers that are no longer brothers will be considered hostile witnesses and the WT will get out of all kinds of trouble since the prosecution will have a hell of a time getting any records. So, they will have their luxury residences for Bethelites while the rest of the JWs are supporting their lifestyle while meeting in basements or rented halls because all the KHs got sold off.

39

At the meeting ... Ugh

by cappytan in

jw
friends

at least i have this forum.

is there a shorthand for referring to this website?

saying jehovahs-witness.com seems like a long winded way..

JWdaughter

Gosh, you guys, I almost wish I was still in so I could give subversive comments during the meetings. I have seen articles when at my moms and -Jeez!! There are so many openings. I can't believe that it isn't a sport for young JWs. You would think that would keep them so busy "commenting" that the 'adults' would get complacent and before you know it-revolution!

I was in Qatar during the Egyptian revolution and every Egyptian I knew wanted to be at home so they could stand in that peaceful protest and tell Mubarak what they thought of him. I now understand the inclination more than before.

You guys-do the rest of us proud! Your moms and dads will be so proud too-they likely won't catch on to you unless they are thinking the same way-and if they are, then they will be proud of you for WHAT they are catching on to.

13

Grandpa died, they didn't say anything

by Sir cid fatos in

hey guys.

my grandpa died recently, for a reason i told my jw friends about it.

and they literally didn't say anything about it at moved on to another subject like nothing happened.

JWdaughter

I'm sorry about your grampa. For most of us, grandparents are very important and valued people in our lives that help form us. It's a BIG loss, no matter what you think will be in the hereafter, in the here and now, we miss the people we love when they pass away.

When you love someone a lot and others can't even give a smidgen of kindness about their passing, it says something about them. That kind of insensitivity seems to indicate a lack of any real intimacy or friendship. OTOH, they may be just socially terribly awkward. Bring it up and see if they can respond with any warmth and think about how good of friends that they truly are/are not.

26

WT's subtle attack on Wikipedia!

by Wonderment in

did anyone notice this wt's subtle attack on wikipedia?

they wrote (from the 2011 yearbook of jehovah's witnesses, pp.

9-10. source: 'tracing all things with accuracy'):.

JWdaughter

I think Wiki is a great place to start-if they offer info without references then you can take if for what it is worth, but when they provide references you can get clued into great (real) source material. I think that they should have acknowledged that because it is true and as a teacher, I have spoken to my students about it several times a semester. It's really a great first step for subjects that are unfamiliar to a researcher or student. I also told them if they EVER used Wiki as their primary source material that they would lose an enormous amount of points for each infraction and it could result in a total fail, regardless of other merits of a paper. (I was a hardass about that).

43

Dear typer-ers, you're doing it wrong!

by Simon in

there are many things wrong with the world, many injustices and crimes committed.

what if we could stop one of them?

wouldn't it make the world a slightly better place?

JWdaughter

Wow! Being an old fart (and yet, under 50), I didn't know that other posters were insulting me with their spacing and being dismissive of what I have to say-before they even know it will be me posting. I WILL take my revenge when it happens again

40

Need advice on a comeback to my wife: when she is in cult mode she says faith without works is dead.

by goingthruthemotions in

so i have gotten into arguements with my wife in the past about this cult.

now a days after reading steve hassan books...i just try and avoid anything jdub with her.

try to keep her in authentic mode..(not sure she really has one).

JWdaughter

I keep hearing these kinds of things from folks married to JW drones and just from my experience with those in the org or any kind of fundy mindset-reasoning only works in your head. Don't let it get to you. Smile,, nod and go on to some other subject or they will make you as crazy as they are.

There is no "comeback" for cluelessness, denial or insanity. Comebacks are just the great lines we think of after it is too late to deliver them. It's pointless to try to change their minds when they are in cult mode, there are no effective words. Just talk to her like a real human when she is in THAT mode.

24

Jehovah's Witnesses recover best from surgery, despite refusing blood.

by nicolaou in

that's' the headline of an article in the sydney morning herald.

my jw family are sharing it with glee on facebook right now.

here's the link; .

JWdaughter

I read of the study a few months ago (if the same study) and my understanding is that these were for not urgent/emergency surgeries where there was plenty of time before hand to make special preparations such as improving the patients overall health and diet and boosting their systems in various ways before hand. It wasnt a fair comparison, really, since they weren't measuring the patients who had all the same preparations and then either rec'd blood or did not. The condition of a patient before going into surgery is critical. The JWs are choosing more skilled surgeons that feel up to the task. I suspect that were it all compared apples to apples, that those rec'ing blood might well do better. . . In fairness though, I think that study SHOULD be done because I am not set out to prove that blood is some magic panacea in medicine. It should be used judiciously in any case and on a case by case basis, there might well be a good reason to choose not to take blood.

But,, when it comes down to it and there is an unexpected loss of blood (and that does happen in enough surgeries that it must be considered), then blood is usually a better choice than exsanguination!

I would hope that whenever possible, all possible preparations are diligently carried out for all patients who anticipate surgery so that blood isn't necessary. When it is given as a bandaid for unskilled surgery, then you will have more issues. I don't need to be defensive of(or in favor of) blood transfusions for the halibut, I am just defensive of the patients who honestly need a transfusion. Getting a transfusion unnecessarily is no wiser than refusing one unconditionally.

Maybe we should all seek out doctors who are comfortable with doing bloodless surgery while letting them know that in life/death situtations, we will accept the blood. Could finally get something useful out of our knowledge of the WTs teachings. Have our cake and eat it too.

That seems kind of mercenary of me, doesn't it?