great thread.
at first i thought this was just another pointless discussion but there are some good points here. I think the main point is that way DFing happens will change but the ultimate end is shunning. We see it already!
The WTS no longer DF's in announcement - "no longer a JW" , then we see the move to bring back inactive ones by offering a study - if they refuse? We all know this will turn into official WTS policy that those faders that do not accept an offer to return will be announced "no longer a JW"
Eventually the WTS will never officially DF anyone - all R&F will "know" that one has, by their own actions, chosen to no longer be a JW. Without having to police the R&F, the WTS can sit back and let the R&F do all the shunning while the WTS shakes hands with politicians.
the R&F will police themselves. The WTS will never have to inflict a punishment on anyone, they just need to "associate" the unwanted with those who are not JW's and let the R&F police themselves. Like crabs in a bucket........