Laser:
Funny how quoting something said years ago is taken as going out of context, which I agree it is. But isn't that what this forum is all about, quoting the WTS for things that happened years and years back.
A discussion board isn't going to have the same consequences of not accepting medical treatment, being shunned, or trapped in abusive relationships. A discussion board isn't going to presume to tell people the status of their relationship with God. There's a somehwat different impact here, yes?
Hillary:
has by default already been reading the Board. They know what to expect when they start posting.
Nope. My bad. I jumped in with both feet as soon as I found the board. And I disagree with your premise that this discussion board is a place where abusive behavior is fine and dandy - as with any community, standards of conduct will be come into play. Those standards will come from both the community (through implicit or explicit negotiation and choices of participation levels) and from the moderators. I reject your seeming "no holds barred" attitude.
PS - you say "Nobody has argued" that "rude is cool or in some way benefical", yet Burn has done that very thing - he relates that he is motivated by rude comments, as below (unless this is sarcasm and it is escaping me).
Burn:
I find that getting flamed convinces me more of the correctness of the other's argument than any logical argumentation. No one ever called me an idiot in the Watchtower so I left. Now I am free to be recieve the kind of offense that can only lead to personal growth.
That's fine for you, and I will never be able to teach you anything (not that you want to be my student!). You may have noticed that you appear to be in a minority, however. I, for one, find it difficult to hear anything you have to say because I have to also contend with what I find abusive and threatening ("Screw you", name calling, inferences that you'd be happy to shoot people that disagree with you). Maybe this is sarcasm on your part, but from what little I know of you from your posts, it's scary that the sarcasm is lost and that this is exactly the persona being generated. I offer this as feedback on your impact, not as an indictment of who you are - I don't know you. The more I read your posts, the less I want to read more.