There were more than a few good looking, handsome guys in my congregation. They all married pioneer sisters and now have the 'perfect' life in the eyes of the JW's. One of them was a total a**hole and doesn't treat his wife very well. The rest were decent guys and seem to be happy.
I can't say that any of them were more attractive than worldly men. I can say for certain that they weren't as 'cool' as the non jw guys.