Eggnogg I'm on the same page with you pretty much the your whole post, minus one point.
There is no due process of law and no defendants in God's organization.
I don't know if you had a minor lapse of thought LOL, or maybe you view the WT as such a bastion of light that you're blinded to all reasonable criticizm of the WT. Egg, its called a Judicial Committee for crying out loud LOL. Judicial as in Judiciary, or Judicature, as in Justice, as in Jury, as in Jurisdiction, you get the point. The accused are in fact defendants, maybe not in a court of law respected by Caesar, but you ask anybody in here who's ever faced a Judical Committee, they probably felt like a defendant. Most probably felt like they knew they were convicted before even showing up. You being an elder, I'm assuming anyway, you've seen your fair share of imperfect brothers who can be heavy handed during their questioning, or one might call interrogating. Some brothers due to imperfections, and personality conflicts with the accused, have axes to grind. I'm younger, but I've been around long enough to have seen that first hand. As far as due process of law, Egg, there's an appeal process, there's witnesses, according to the new book if my memory serves me correct the witnesses don't even have to be Jehovah's, if you catch my drift. After the defendant has been convicted, its put on his permanent record, and even sent to the brothers in New York. You can liken the private reproval to a misdemeanor, and the DFing to a felony conviction. Since we're discussing marital infedility and grounds for scriptural divorce, there are some choice articles in the WT CD Rom about new evidence coming up after the Judicial committee settled the matter. When that occurs, they sometimes pursue a new judical committee, one might call it a retrial, with new evidence.
Egg, make no mistake about it, there is due process and defendants, and a whole lot more that resembles Caesar's laws and processes.