Essan, all respect (from my heart, mate, I mean it!) to you for engaging with Cons over the weeks - you have more patience than I have!
I think we're slightly talking at cross-purposes here though. We agree that debate is good, but what got me going was Simon's implication that he's banned Cons. You made a comment...
Surely continual deliberate lying shouldn't be tolerated here?
I understand "shouldn't be tolerated" as supporting a banning. So this is where we differ, since he (or she, whatever) is breaking no actual rules, just making him/herself look a bit silly.
This is where I'm coming from. I look like a newbie but I've been around this board community for many years and I've seen some incredible posters, some extremely useful to the ex-JW cause, even people who have contributed life-changing research to the JWD archive, being banned by Simon for differences of opinion, not breaking forum rules. So I don't want to see that starting up again.
So this is my way of trying to nip the disease in the bud. Hope you understand.