Zid,
I am glad to hear you are opening your heart and mind. The best advice I was given was to go "Church Surfing". I eventually settled on a local Methodist congregation here in town after years of visiting several churces. My main reasons for joining were two fold.
1)There is a big emphasis on service and personal growth in the UMC faith. I found many churches focused on faith and salvation but, no real works (unless you mean writing a check which is important too). Maybe this ressonated with me as being raised JW in a "works based" belief but it still feels right for me.
2) They respect and feel that the christian "traditions" that the JW's knock on all the time add benefit and context to worship and our lives as christians. They don't nit pick and hyper-analyze things and lose the whole point. I was very uncomfortable watching my first infant baptism but when I absorbed the big picture it was beautiful. It was actually a Chirstening were the family (extended as well) and the whole congregation took an oath to love, forgive and be there for this child regardless of his decisions.
Good luck in your experiment. I know you will be blessed and meet some great people. Don't be afraid to ask hard questions like about the Trinity etc... from any leaders you might meet. I find most welcome an honest chance to discuss the more mysterious aspects of faith if asked respectfully (not like we did in field service). I had some great open minded and honest discussions that would never happen with an Elder at the KH. It's like going from East Germany to the USA sometimes. What's the point of going to church if people can't speak freely about their problems, doubts and struggles with faith?
-Cage