Richard,
Because of who you think I am, you have read FAR TOO MUCH into my posts.
I have NEVER espoused reparations, only pointed out some valid arguments for the legal precedents which have been set in this and other lands.
My position is more similar to Julie's than either YOURS or UR's, which I think are both hardline leftist and rightist.
You say that :
You also struggle with contextual issues regarding my statements about American Indians. You and I both know that I was talking about American Indians at the time the Europeans settled this country. Not contempory American life and Indians
so easily. You refer to 'civilization' and 'nomadic savages', but then backpedal and say you're referring to Indians 'a long time ago.'
Without the Indian's assistance, white man would have never survived the first winter. That's why we celebrate Thanksgiving.
In thanks, the white man bought Manhattan Island for a boxful of cheap trinkets, shortly after they kindly handed out smallpox infected blankets.
Now who was civilized and who were savages?
All things that are legal are not advantageous, as the Apostle Paul pointed out.
There is NO RACE that is above reproach on matters of how they treat their fellow human beings. BlackMan succinctly stated, if the shoe were on the other foot, whites would have been treated just as badly.
AMEN.
I don't think my white relatives were 'the Great Satan.' Neither do I think blacks are free from culpability in the way they use the opportunities they have access to.
You say I am emotional. Perhaps you are right. Since I read articles two months ago about the chocolate industry and slave labor, I can't bring myself to eat a chocolate bar.
http://www.mft.co.uk/
* http://news.bbc.co.uk/hi/english/world/africa/newsid_946000/946952.stm
For sure, there's no white slave owners on Africa's Ivory coast. That doesn't make it any more palatable for me. If you can eat a choclate bar without thinking of a little 6 yr old that's been abducted to pick cacao beans, so be it. I can't. If that makes me emotional, so be it. I put my money where my mouth is. Or in this case, isn't.
I surely didn't start slavery, I mentioned my family never owned slaves. I didn't stop it either. At 32, I'm too young to remember most of the civil rights struggle.
However, it is my responsibility to leave the world a better place. That is the burden I have.
I didn't answer your question on reparations because most of them are hypothetical, and can't be answered. Responsiblity, guilt, nor victimization can ever be bought and paid for.
There are, however, things our society can and must do. And until we willingly step up to the plate and accept responsilibity, we're gonna keep on hearing about reparations.
I do find it odd that Bill Clinton went to Africa and apologised to the Africans for slavery, but never had the balls to do it in this country! Why? An apology means you've accepted responsibility!
I would far prefer it if our leaders would have the balls to say, "Slavery is a scar on this great nation's sould. We won't pay ONE RED CENT in reparations. We will, however, ......."
I hope I live to see that day.
And you too.