When I first started taking the witness religion seriously , when I was about 17 ,a pioneer brother who I was working with asked me "would you do anything God asked?"
I said "no , only if it was reasonable."
He said that anything God asked would by definition, be reasonable.
Or in other words , as long as God asks it , its the right thing to do.
I didn't see that as logical then , and that kind of thinking gradualy lead to my leaving.
May witnesses do think the org. is God.
If they think like that brother , then anything they ask must be right, in their minds.
"These people are lost, but you have to give them at least a small measure of credit. To even ask if they would kill under orders from the GB or spit on householders is just plain ridiculous and hypothetical beyond reason."
These things may sound stupid , but already witnesses are doing very similair things.
I am shunned , how big a difference betwwen turning away from a person, or spiting at them?
Parents have let their children die, how fine a line between letting people die and killing them?
Maybe there are two camps of witnesses.
Those who believe it because they think its logical and backed up by evidence.If evidence was lacking they would leave.
Those who believe it because they think its Gods word and will do anything asked of them.If evidence was lacking they would strenghten their faith.
Those of the former camp gradualy get here.
The others,are just waiting for new orders.