blacksheep: I love your nickname, btw
Any insight? Why the HOT and COLD treatment? Seems to be a common theme with witness treatment towards da'd df'd relatives. What gives? Is it intentional? Why can't they just be somewhat consistent? If they DON'T believe they should be talking to me, then fine. Cut off the relationship. But I'm starting to REALLY resent the guessing game. And I DON'T want to subject my kids to it either.
Personally, I think they are struggling with the contradiction between 1) being "faithful to Jehovah" and 2) being faithful to their own instincts, IE not completely cutting themselves off from their own flesh and blood... They *want* to know (naturally) what's going on in our lives, but the WTS tells them it is wrong to act on this desire. And (naturally) they have no idea exactly where the line is; if you have constant contact with a DF'd/DA'd relative, can you be disfellowshipped (it kind of depends on which body of elders you're dealing with, as well as how discreet you are)? And, if not, does Jehovah view you with enough displeasure that you're not going to make it through Armageddon anyway, despite being a "Witness in good standing?" They are trying to sort through their own feelings, and it is hard for them to have a complete courage of their convictions, because it would be unnatural to simply view you as "one who is dead," as the WTS tells them to do.
I'm not trying to apologize for them; personally I hate it. I think it's two-faced and gives the lie to their "beliefs." And I don't have kids, but if and when I do, I WILL NOT subject them to ANY association with "family" that considers us to be birdseed. I'm not sure how I would explain the situation to my kids, but I think it would be necessary to somehow explain it, and do so truthfully... Otherwise, when they get older, and find out they have grandparents, and other family out there that they never knew before, you run the risk of those JW family members being the ones to "explain" the situation to them. And then you run the risk of losing your children to the borg As they say, "turnabout is fair play." Your JW family wouldn't let *you* get near their children in any situation where you could "corrupt" them, and I would suggest you take the same view toward them, where *your* children are concerned.
best wishes, Spidey