Oh, boy
What have I done?
Gregor,
What is this success you point out as the merit of capitalism?
Gee, I don't know where to start. How about highest standard of living in the world. Longest average life span, greatest amount of personal freedom and a miniscule fraction who renounce their citizenship, not to mention that our poor are fighting obesity, not starvation, just to mention a few.
The indicator of success you suggest is that others want to immigrate to the US. Why do they want to immigrate?
See above.
I suspect we can agree it is not because they have made a rational investigation of political/economic systems and choose ours.
You suspect wrong. See above.
Do you not agree most who 'want to immigrate' feel a bit disadvantaged and want a piece of the pie? Does this make ours the best system? Simply being the object of desire does not make us the best, anymore than being the hottest soccer mom in the neighborhood makes a her the best woman or human. It's flawed reasoning. Perhaps the "critics" are looking at something deeper.
This statement is so convoluted and trite I don't know what to say. The US as a sexy soccer mom drawing immigrants to their doom? That's just dippy.
As for Simon and HS disliking the country, maybe you are taking their ideology personally. I'm inclined to think they are pointing out flaws in ideas and policies of a system rather then dissing the pretty soccer mom that everyone wants.
When someone only focuses on your personal flaws and never has anything nice to say about you would you feel that they dislike you? duh. I repeat, whether they like or dislike this country means less than nothing to me. But it is rather obvious.
I will don't think I will address this other than, you completely ignored the reason for immigration I suggested and you give absolutely no evidence to support an off handed dismissal. I thought you would agree but considering your reasoned response I think I need to just let this go.
Journey-on,
I'm too tired to be serious. I'm reminded of the statement that America is the only place in the world where 'a poor black child can grow up to become a rich white woman'. But that's irrelevant. I'm sorry. As for America being a land of opportunity, things change. Now, instead of growing up learning the family business or learning a profitable trade from scratch, our land of opportunity is limited to getting a degree, preferably in a prestigious university, so that we have the "opportunity" if getting a fair paying job with a major corporation. But this is not a local problem. The entire western world has become limited to this 'opportunity'
You have NO IDEA the story I could tell you! Why do you think I'm so adamant about this?
I'm inclined to believe those of you that rant against the American system are those that have failed to take advantage of it. You've failed in some way and are disappointed to the degree that you want to blame anything and anybody but yourselves for your failures or your lack of achievement.
Dude, without knowing anything about me you suggest I'm a looser and simply do not share your belief system because I '"failed" in attempting to take advantage of the wonderful "American system". Please, how do I respond to such nonsense without sounding like a capitalist I despise. I have been DAMN successful but I will not lower myself to proving it it this context. HS as well, if he will forgive me, has been VERY successful. Maybe in a more private situation, if you care to know the truth, I will dispell your misconceptions about the capitalistic successes of the people you suggest are failures. But not tonight. PM me if you sincerely want to evolve.
Steve