I hesitate to get into this with HS. He's incorrigible....lol
But my simple answer to why socialism WILL NOT work in America is because too many of us are INDIVIDUALISTS. Socialism makes for mediocrity. It would take the wind out of the American spirit.
Americans are kind, generous, and helpful to those who reach out for themselves and make an attempt to better themselves.
Too many, however, sit back on their laurels and wait for that government check to arrive and think they deserve it in some way. (some do..some don't)
My daughter-in-law used an excellent analogy when explaining this to her 13-yr. old:
"You work hard for that straight A report card, don’t you?"
"Yes, I do."
"Now, what if I told you that Katie, who doesn’t work very hard and is perfectly content to make C’s and D’s thinks it’s unfair that you get all those A’s. She wants some of your A’s. So, here’s what I’m going to do…I’m going to take a few of the A’s you worked for and give them to her. You can replace them with a few of her C’s and D’s. Now you are even.
But, that’s not fair! I worked hard for my A’s.
Yes, but, Katie doesn’t have any. She wants some of what you worked for! If we give her some of yours, then everybody will have the same share! Everybody will be even….
_____________