>>that if god punishes children for the sins of their forefathers, god is being unjust. You mentioning that everyone is a sinner is not pertinant;<<
Deut 24:16
16 Fathers shall not be put to death for their children, nor children put to death for their fathers; each is to die for his own sin.
When one is put to death at the hand of God, it is for the individuals own sin. Including children. Which means when children were put down by God, it was obviously for the inheirted type of sin as they are not capable of performing intellectual sin. Simple logic.
"Punishment" from God was not always the death sentence. Examine your Bible. Find the times God punished children for their fathers error without death. There are many many times. Like wandering through the wilderness for 40 years. The children were punished for the sins of their forefathers. They were NOT put to death. But they were punished.
Punishment = death/not death
Sin = death
Does God have the right to terminate a babies life on account of inherited sin? YES HE DOES. But He also has the right to resurrect whoever He wants too. If God brings down a baby in sin, a just God would bring it back up in righteousness. That is Justice.
>>>Now, as you seem to be a Biblical literalist, I'll be interested to see how you can interpret that otherwise.<<
See the above.
>>As good an arguement by a creationist as any; "I shit therefore god made me". You don't really need anyone to parody you, do you? You do quite well on your own!<<
In with the good, out with the bad. The body mimicks the eventual reality of ALL creation.
>>I suppose you are talking about 'inherited' guilt. The sin we inherit from Adam. So even if we are talking about this, your god is still punishing people for another person's sin. Is that fair? Even a child could tell you that isn't fair.<<
Well, are you blaming God for inherited sin, because that is the issue? The blame should be on the CAUSE of the sin should it not?Satan? If you read your Bible with open eyes a procreative species would be perfectly GOOD if not contaminated. So are you going to put the blame on God for a corruption He didn't create? Just because He made a creation that passed everything down does not make God UNJUST. The injustice comes from Satan. Even a child could read the Genesis account and identify the BAD, and the child would positively NOT point the finger at God. But you do?
>>I am saying that I find punishing people for other people's sins is wrong. I make no statement regarding any other morals I may or may not have.<<
Well, who put the punishment in motion??? God did not and you can't say He did. Satan brought all evil into the world AS SOMETHING NEW, and it was corrupting everyone God creatd. There would be NOTHING unscathed by this hate monger. It was like an infectious bacteria that would spread, and did spread.
God created Adam and Eve as a species that would pass down GOOD. Satan caused this GOOD species to pass down BAD. Who's fault?
>>Well, we just have to disagree. I actually think it's not just a disagreement, but a fundamental failure on your part to comprehend the situation. To me, even if god DID create us, if god DOES punish people for other people's sins, then worshipping it would be approving these unjust actions.<<
Again, the source of the first sin, is the source of the death. Which is not God. Procreative species are good, they would pass on life. Contaminated procreative species are bad, they would pass on death. You and I are the latter. The latter is NOT God's creation, it is Satan's. Since the latter is NOT God's and is defiled, he can with FULL JUSTIFICATION destroy anything that is corrupt and not His own.
The latter was permitted by God so as to start the ball rolling to get rid of the source of the corruption. It all has to do with bringing LAW into existence, so the one who is the true source of INJUSTICE can be put down. Making Law would take time.
>>I cannot do that, it offends my conscience. You might not see its actions as unjust, but I see not one arguement on your part to this end. You are just saying my opinion is wrong. Why not prove me wrong? Show the ignorance of my statement.<<
A tid bit. There was NO LAW in heaven against what Satan was doing. So He went on doing what he was doing assuming that there could be nothing God could do to stop him. Ever. When there is no Law, sin (breaking law) is not AND CANNOT be taken into account now can it?
God is so just, that He could not put Satan down because there was NO LAW that Satan broke with an attached punishment. God would fix that problem by bringing LAW into being through another creation called mankind.
>>No, the one giving life is not instantly deserving of worship. That is like saying that ALL fathers deserve respect, even those that abuse their children.<<
When the one WHO IS GOD gives anyone THE GIFT OF LIFE, and this God by creative example glows as the epitome' of all the LOVE there could ever be, the one who dares insinuate that God abuses His children is the one who's shoes I would care NOT to walk in.
>>As for being an accessory to child rape, I suggest you read the Biblical account of the ethnic cleansing of Palestine by the Israelites. There are several instances where the Israelites were commanded to kill adult men and women, and boy children, but to keep the virgin females alive. Given the rules regarding concubinage and slavery in the law, to imagine all these virgin girls would then engage in consensual sexual intercourse with the soldiers who killed their entire family is stupidity.<<
That's what I thought. Total YOU fabrication that I would not even hesitate to call an out right lie. Keep your lies out of this debate. If you state something as bold as God beiong an accessory to rape, you better come up with the PROOF, not ridiculous lying speculations
Why do I get the gut feeling you were raped? Any one that can read that balshpemy into the Bible must have something personal behind it.
>>You're the one who has to prove that the punishment of children for other people's sins is a moral action!<<
>>I have no problem if you want to believe in god Pom, go ahead. But believing the Bible is an accurate representation of any god is foolishness, for reasons such as the ones I have outlined.<<
The above statement is made in your ignorance, which can be fixed. If the tool to fix it comes along and you refuse it, your ignorance becomes stupidity.