(This story is fairly disturbing. Pretty much just like the bible.)
Long ago, in a galaxy far, far away - there was a man named Ted. Ted had a 9 year old son named Bobby. One day, Bobby was playing baseball in the yard and hit a fowl ball - send the baseball crashing through the living room window. Hearing the crash, Ted came out to inspect what had happened.
"Did you break this window, Bobby?" Ted asked.
Frightened by his father's anger and inexperienced Bobby defensively replied "no".
So, Ted took Bobby down into the basement, where he tied him to a chair. Ted poured gasoline all over Bobby, and all over the floor of the basement, scolded Bobby for lying, and then lit a match and dropped it on the floor. Ted closed the door of the basement.
But magically.. Bobby didn't die.
50,000,000,000,000,000,000,000,000,000,000,000,000,000,000,000,000,000,000,000,000,000,000,000,000 years later - long after the sun had burned up all of it's solar fuel, swallowed the planet, and in a giant supernova scattered the remains of the solar system across the universe; and one by one all the stars winked out of existence, until the whole universe was dark... and every day before and after that... Bobby was still screaming in agony.
Bobby had long since forgotten his name, he had forgotten what baseball was, he had forgotten how to speak. It had been so long since bobby wasn't in constant torment that he had even lost the ability to think. It had been trillions of years since he could formulate the tiniest shred of a thought about that fowl ball that led him here. But now, he no longer had any memory of anything - all he knew anymore was the unending agony of his own burning flesh.
That morning, the door creaked open. Ted walked into the room, poured a can of gasoline on Bobby, poured some out on the floor, and leaving the room, he lit it on fire.
- Lime
PS: It doesn't really matter if Bobby lied, or killed someone, or was Satan himself. The result is the same. At some point, the suffering caused by the 'sinner' is completely dwarfed and forgotten compared to the suffering caused by the torturer. And that is not "justice".