"The odds of 1111111 coming up are exactly the same as any other seven digit number coming up."
Your example lacks personal meaning since the crowd was just wowed by a simple pattern of one number over and over. My cards example contains heavy personal significance for two people: my brother and I. Therefore, I find it perfectly logical that you cannot accept my revelation since you don't take any personal significance from the cards that were dealt; to you it's just as significant as the "1's example"... and maybe that's a good thing, you are not swayed by a strong experience, on my part, and you are holding steadfast to your values and what is important to you. I applaud that kind of behaviour and would never criticize you for it...
-Sab