Welcome CG,
While I am not an athiest, and I have only exited the religion of my youth in the past year. I can appreciate some of the conundrums raised by athiests, and think it is safe to say that ANY of us decide something that shapes our world view ad much as belief in a benevolent creator, it shapes how we view the world. Certainly your world is viewed through the lenses of Jesus Christ being God in the flesh for a time being. Athiests lenses are colored with the belief there is no benevolent creator. Bias is there on both sides. Just sayin...
I enjoyed how you presented the thoughts you did. Although i will say kicking the men out of your home for perverting the word of God after you invited them in and they came back.....was a dick move. It was high and mighty, and you may want to consider your approach. Especially because you had esentially considered the end of the matter before it even occured.
Just some food for thought.