Seeker, I was commenting on the bad CG, not on the fact that "Shrek" wasn't in the book. Another certain creature was, though, not "Shrek."
Also, re-read Lothlorien, in Fellowship. You'll see that there was just a moment where she seemed dangerous, not some goofy transformation. I read it five times, and I couldn't understand why Jackson would ruin that part by doing that. "Beautiful and Terrible", just doesn't meld with the silly effect Jackson chose. It ruined it for me.
Bilbo's character was OK, and I did understand what Jackson was getting at with the "large-marge" eyes, but it was just excess....that's the whole film's problem.
As for Arwen, it was the lines at the river where I was irritated.
I DID think that the Rignwraiths were fairly cool, and the "ghosts of the kings" at Weathertop was interesting. I did like that a lot. I never thought of it that way....brought a lot to the scene at Weathertop.
I just HATE Peter Jackson's direction, though. The screenplay could have been better.
I understand what you're saying about the chapter titles being a tribute to the fans, but did it HAVE to be in there? Not really. It broke up the flow for me. Just seeing his eyes look bemused as he drove by would have been subtle and sufficient.
i still contend that Sam was wasted. I LIKE the actor who played him. I enjoyed a couple of the scenes with him and Sam, but there just wasn't enough of him.
Really, though, the actors I can take. Even some of the shoddy direction. But they really could have tightened up the script, took out the "dwarf-tossing" joke, and left out farmer Maggot, and just had the four leave the shire the way the book spoke of.
I know that having Tom Bombadil is too much to ask, but at 3 hr 15, they could have fit him in, as well as read the Lower Bronx phone book, A-Z.
As for Viggo, it's not his look, but his awful dialouge delivery that was irritating.
I thought I was going to hate the scenery, but I didn't. Thought I was going to hate Gandalf's rendering, but I didn't. Just a lot that I don't agree with.
Peter Jackson said, I'm not making Tolkien's Lord of the Rings, I'm making Peter Jackson's Lord of the Rings. Well, shouldn't he be faithful to the book in mood as well as script?
ashi