Julia Orwell:
Consider that a relatively small amount of people come here via boats but they're visible and easy to be for political target practice. Less visible are the ones who come on holiday, students or working visas and simply don't get back on the plane. They disappear into the cities and get cash jobs.
Both sides of politics in Australia play with the whole issue like it's a political football, which is kind of pathetic.
Seeking asylum is not illegal, and isn't the same as illegally remaining in the country after arriving on a travel visa. However, most genuine asylum seekers arriving in Australia do come by plane.
But something should be done to discourage people from getting on boats arranged by people smugglers. Not because it's illegal. And certainly not because Australia is being 'overrun' by 'boat people'. But because it is dangerous.
The alternative offered by the conservatives to magically "stop the boats" is incredibly naive, and ignores the fact that other international factors quite apart from lame political slogans are the cause of people taking the risk on a leaky boat. And the claim that they'll just 'turn the boats around' (but "only when it's safe to do so") is another meaningless catchphrase, because it's basically never safe to do so.
smiddy:
And to be fair it will put a brake on the amount of boatloads of people coming here , and of course the potential danger of drownings that we have seen in the past.
I don't think it would be improper to settle people in PNG instead of Australia (though nor do I think it would 'stop the boats'). And Australia's territorial waters go just about to the beach of PNG, so if they are escorted that far, they'd be far less likely to drown than being marooned at Indonesia's boundary.
doofdaddy:
It appears (if we can trust the media) is that these people fly into Indonesia, which obviously requires a passport, get a Visa On Arrival which is basically a stamp for $25 US, burn their passports and any documentation and pay to be taken by leakey boat which gets a sympathy vote from the media and wait for the Aust navy to "rescue" them.
Ah, you mean the 'politically neutral' Australian media?