Snoozy
but Being a JW was his choice..I respected that boundary..as I expected him to do mine..which he didn't..after all , he was still a JW..
Isn't that what Flipper just highlighted? The JW's DON'T respect boundaries, thats the problem. Flip suggested a quiet word by sinis to his mom about respecting those boundaries.
she should ask the wife directly and the wife should speak for herself..if she didn't know what to say then it is her problem to grow a backbone and say no or go
Its all very well you saying "grow a backbone" but for many people that doesn't come easy depending on their personality and character. Whilst I agree with you that respect is important, so is support when someone is being intimidated by a forceful JW. Sinis is in the best position to judge if his partner needed support or not.
So lets play out some hypothetical situations.
MIL asks partner to the memorial, partner doesn't want to go but feels intimidated by MIL due to the endtimes conversation and isn't familiar with the doublespeak and false arguments being used. She reluctantly agrees to go to be polite.
Sinis respects her decision.
After the memorial which she doesn't understand, she again reluctantly agrees to a bible study with MIL.
Sinis respects her decision.
MIL pins her down to a definate day for the study, refusing to be put off by excuses. Partner is taken through the "Bible Teach" book with MIL. Still nobody warns her about the double speak and the insider doctrines. She starts to see the "logic" behind the way she's being taught.
Sinis respects her decision.
She progresses well and starts to be suckered into the Witnesses. She spends more time at the meetings, qualifies for FS and decides to be baptised. She insists on Sinis marrying her or she leaves.
Sinis, not wanting to marry, respects her decision to leave.
The relationship breaks up. Sinis is left without the woman he loves and the Witnesses have a new recruit.
A purely hypothetical situation but one that could have been avoided if Partner had some support in dealing with the forceful MIL in the first place.
And if this really was a true scenario, would we now been lambasting sinis for not protecting his partner and his relationship when he had the chance?