Thanks Blondie...
This does not surprise me, this quoting "scholars" in their footnotes without properly attributing the quote, or more likely taking a quote out of context to suit the purposes of the Society.
I have found this particular set of phenomena prevalent in my college courses as well. Except that it is no longer phenomena, it is now commonplace. In one of my online discussion forums for college (macroeconomics), one assignment each week is to address whatever topic question(s) are provided by the instructor and use scholarly resources to back up our postings. I do not believe that proper scholarly research is taught in high school, based on the postings I see on the online course forum. Fellow students either give their own Big Media influenced, biased opinion or they quote wikipedia, an ever changing, unverified, unvetted internet resource that is great for throwing trivial facts to the wind, but not acceptable for scholarly research. Some so-called research links even end in .blogspot.com. When was a blog considered a legitimate research source?
When I mentioned this sad fact to the instructor (in person and via email), he told me that this is what is coming out of the education system these days. This instructor has been teaching at this college for three decades plus...before it was its current incarnation. He says he addresses it privately but it does no good. He agreed that students are lazy in their so-called "research."
I provide that anectdote to just show that WTBTS writers are not alone in their poor "research" methodology. Since WTBTS/GB does not encourage anything past a high school education anyway, are we surprised by the continued degradation of already poor writing by the Watchtower Society? I am not. The Society is aiming for the lowest common denominator in the education level of its members. Quite honestly, it is the only reason that they recruit or retain anyone in the Jehovah's Witness "religion." Anyone with half a brain, and no emotional or familial ties to the religion, won't put up with it. I feel for those who know JW is a crock o' $hit and have to keep going to keep family ties.
Snakes ()