It really takes guts to post on this board Humble. I give you that. However I do have some comments about what you said.
"The 'prodigal son' illustration was used by Jesus to show Jehovah's love for those that repent from their wrongdoings. He did not go into details on how the father handled the situation."
- Then how can anyone including the Society SPECULATE about how he handled things afterwards?? Do you read what you say? They could just have easily said what happened between the time Jesus was 12 and when he was 30 as say what happened after this banquet...and oh by the way. ITS AN ILLUSTRATION. You know..just like the ILLUSTRATION about the "Faithful and Discreet Slave" which the Society also somehow made into a literal group, like the 144,000 of Revelation.
"For example, what happened after the banquet? Where there any repercussions to the prodigal son's actions?"
- If the father forgave the son and welcomed him with open arms and had a party for him and then subsequently punished the guy when all the witnesses to his behavior at the party were gone home, that would only be INCREDIBLY hypocritical and werent you just saying this Father was Jehovah? Is Jehovah two faced? Again, why does the Society or you, assume that the son was subsequently punished and that his coming home and humbling himself to his father and being FORGIVEN BY HIS FATHER wasnt the END of it? If he was repentent...that IS the end of it. There would be no need to "prove" anything to anybody. If that were the case, he would NOT have been "forgiven" yet like the Society says...you cant be forgiven and reinstated until you "do time".
"One thing is for sure, it is a beautiful illustration of compassion and forgiveness from he Almighty, Jehovah."
Yes it does show jehovahs forgiveness which is immediate and the sin FORGOTTEN. It in no WAY comes CLOSE to the way the Society/Elders treat the sheep in actuality. Love does NOT keep account of the error. The society and the Judicial Committees are anything BUT forgiving and forgetting entities, and that person's "sin" follows them even to death as a Jw and is a permanent part of his record.
"Now, why are there restrictions after being reinstated?
First of all, it is true that the discipline is being disfellowshipped, but can the elders in the judicial committee read the persons' heart. Of course not, only Jehovah can do that. Anyone can cry and say that they have changed their ways. Restrictions allow elders to see the persons' true motives and these restrictions are lifted when the reinstated person asks for them to be lifted. Of course, this happens one at a time. The last restriction to be lifted is the priviledge of representing the congregation in prayer."
You just contradicted yourself. If the elders do not have the ability to determine a person's heart condition at the time of their "sentencing" what gives them that ability 10 days or 5 months or 4 years later to give him his "privilege" of being treated like a human being, back again? Answer: They dont. They dont EVER have the ability to give nor take anyone's status before God. The entire punishment is to make them a spectacle to others and humiliate them. Their relationship with God is neither proven nor disproven by their ability to fool people in the congregation...least of all the elders. The whole scene is a mockery of Jehovahs forgiveness.
"The final purpose of all these procedures is that the person that has sinned will have a clean conscience and be able to serve Jehovah with a clean record."
Again...that person's record in the congregation will never ever again be "clean" and no one will ever treat them the same. If they ever change congregations, their records follow them and they will once again have to "prove" themselves to the hypocrites there who dare to judge them. That person's conscience is CLEAN immediately upon his prayer of repentance to Jehovah. Not one single moment later. And that happens not when the SOCIETY decides it did..but when God and that person say it did. Are you going to tell me that you and the "friends" dont whisper about others and say "did you know Sister So-and-so was difellowshipped? She was only recently reinstated! Can you believe it?" If you say that doesnt happen...stop RIGHT there and check yourself.
The elders sit there like little Grand Poobahs with giant fuzzy animal hats, passing judgement on peoples LIVES like God himself came down and handed them the keys, destroying lives and families with the stroke of a pen and the wave of a hand and an announcement to the hall. POOF...one more life destroyed for, say...joining the YMCA.
"Gods" Organization indeed....if this is GODS organization, then David Koresh was indeed Jesus.
And oh by the way...you can be repentent and STILL be disfellowshipped becuase they HAVE to make an example of you so dont even go there. The more people that "know" about your "sin" the longer your sentence will be.
As for that party when the son returned...if this is an accurate illustration of how the SOCIETY does things, then why do they say absolutely NO PARTIES for those who are reinstated? Comical really... if it wasnt so sad. They have you by the short hairs.