I have started a list of oddball/wierdball 'doctrines' that JW's have in addition to what the rest of the world (theological or not) considers normal religious fare.
As D_W stated, you have made some serious points. So, I added your discussion and link to my list. I will be giving this some thought and watch for response.
BTW, this is the list so far:
THE DOCTRINE OF NEW LIGHT
THE DOCTRINE OF 'HARBORING PRIVATE IDEAS'
THE DOCTRINE OF 'IMPERFECT MEN'
THE DOCTRINE OF CLERGY-LAITY DISTINCTION
THE DOCTRINE OF JUDGING
THE DOCTRINE OF 'OVERZEALOUS BROTHERS'
THE DOCTRINE OF 'WHERE WILL YOU GO'
I collect pertinent commentary from others and add my own editorial comments to this list. Using links/URL's and hypertext, I am compiling a 'mini-book' on these subjects.
Notice the inclusion of the relatively new 'HARBORING PRIVATE IDEAS'. THE recent WT article that formalizes this launches this 'new light', LOL. I am awaiting reports of the first DF'ing based on this article. I'm sure that this has been done in the past, but not so stated.
These off-the-wall doctrines seem to be a great part of the glue that binds the JW's together. They form the greater part of the
'mud'/mortar that is daubed over the chinks in a Dubs personality to keep them firmly in line with CURRENT Dub policy.
These obscure doctrines are more fascinating than the standard Hell-fire and Trinity fare that are getting so boring.
Mustang