Jgnat you said:
I notice that Witnesses brush that whole angelic host singing to the new-born King thing under the carpet (Luke 2). No shame in celebrating a birth.
This is simply too easy to refute from JW's. I'm not sure why its ever used. EVERYONE rejoices at a birth. its the reoccuring rejoicement that is apparently evil. JW's would say they have no problem with rejoicing at abirth, bringing presents (shower), flowers (hospital), celebrating, etc... That won't go anywhere.
Personally, I don't think we could ever make the jump to Christmas. I just think the JW's have something on it not being cool. In addition, the ridiculousness surrounding it, and the 4th quarter economic principles that drive it, just are not my favorite. So no tree in our house, although because it is part of the culture, I will most likely send some things to some of my clients.
Tell your wife that surely going to spend time with family on a day they happen to all be together cannot be wrong in and of itself. They know we don't do it, and won't be exchanging presents, and that should be good enough. In fact, we could be giving a bad witness by not being willing to bend when they already know our stance...
something liek that. My mother was a hard core JW with the best of them, but we always went to Thanksgiving because "that was when the family happened to be together". It was great. We all still go.