In Judaism, only the offended party can forgive you your sin. You must make amends or pay a fine. That is why murder cannot be forgiven; the deceased is not around to accept your apology or restitution! (Ere the Jews were scandalized by Jesus' forgiving of others' sins.)
Who is the offended party to Adam's sin? Was Adam's death payment for the sin of disobedience? How about, death is the natural and only consequence of any creation distancing one's self away from God? If Jesus has to take the place of Adam (while alive) and pay restitution for the sin of disobedience; to whom is the price paid but to the offended party (God). ??
Jesus is the offended party, takes the place of the offender and then dies in order to make amends for the offence he committed against himself!!! Paradoxes aplenty. Jesus also called himself Alpha and Omega in Revelation. He has all angles covered.
Even if Jesus is not god you have the innocent party (Jesus) being punished for the guilty party (Adam) as well as making just one death (Jesus') expand quantitatively to cover the deaths of billions of humans (Adam's offspring). Pretty good bang for one death. Are you complaining?
The payment of the innocent person's death is paid to the innocent person's own Dad who allows this transaction to occur and calls it JUSTICE!! It seems more like mercy than justice to me (even though it is both).
The offended party is God, right? In what way was God, jehovah or jesus god offended to the extent 6000+ years of human suffering and death were not enough to quell the sense of damage?? Human life, death, pain, and freedom and the holiness of God are not shallow subjects. Treating them like a quick math problem is not ever going to reveal the reality that God sees.
Why is Jesus death as a demi-god, god, son of god (take your pick) so similar to the pagan idea of the death and resurrection of their make believe deities? How did the unbelieving pagans correctly guess the sacred secret???? Surprise! God loves unbelieving pagans enough to show them something meaningful and helpful. God's a bit more helpful and gratuitous than we can suspect (and much more than the WTS teaches).
bebu