The Need To Question Atheism

by The wanderer 142 Replies latest jw friends

  • Hortensia
    Hortensia

    well, I guess from an evolutionary standpoint, we aren't born to die, we are born to reproduce, because we die. I don't call myself anything, atheist, agnostic, whatever, but I don't believe there is a god and any evidence that is presented to prove there is a god would have to be very clear and not able to be explained by anything else.

    I have to add that I saw a UFO a couple of times - and to me it wasn't aliens from outer space, just some flying thing I couldn't identify that looked like the ones they show on television. No evidence to show it was anything other than something manmade. I think belief in god and belief in UFOs are kind of similar, both with very little evidence.

  • DanTheMan
    DanTheMan

    I tend to be skeptical of those who enthusiastically say things along the lines of, "you have to create your own meaning!"

    Birthrates among white Europeans have been falling for years. I think this is because of their failure to find a sense of purpose in their (much moreso than the USA) post-Christian cultural milieu.

    I'm not saying these things as an argument for belief. I'm just uncertain as to whether or not people that don't perceive that there's an externally sanctioned purpose to their lives lives find enough mmph in life to ensure that it continues. I know I sure don't.

  • nvrgnbk
    nvrgnbk
    one can infer a meaning that seems cold and empty. That is, to procreate and make sure our genes carry on to the next generation.

    I am unclear on the point you are making here Mavie. What about procreation and making sure our genes carry on to the next generation is inherently cold and empty? I find it to be most warm and noble.

    Respectfully,

    Nvr

  • Vinny
    Vinny

    It's time to play BURY THE ATHEIST. This is too easy. Nothing personal Seeker.






























    Let's just imagine that you are completely alone in the middle of North Dakota somewhere, surrounded by nothing but mountainous wilderness, no people, no buildings, just you alone and the wilderness for hundreds of miles. And right there in the middle of it all you suddenly walk up to a brand new Red Chevrolet Corvette, unlocked, with the keys in the ignition, a full tank of gas and one road taking you out. Now, it would in my opinion be nothing short of preposterous, actually INSANE to even entertain the mere possibility if someone were to try telling you that THAT brand new Red Corvette just happened to get there, on its own, without any intelligent designer behind it whatsoever. That somehow, some way it just happened to be some product of "blind chance" without any intellectual forces behind that ready to drive automobile.


    That all the parts just "happened" to come together absolutely perfectly through some abiogenesis/evolutionary chain of events. A primordial "soup" if you will that eventually evolved into that beautiful automobile ready to take off. Who of us out here would even consider such an outrageous suggestion as this? Okay sure, the natural elements just happened to create eight perfectly designed and gapped spark plugs, placed precisely into their sockets, tightened down exactly as needed. The spark plug wires too just happened to fall into place connecting to all eight plugs, while coincidentally also connecting to a computer chip, a continuously self calibrating one (that happened to just come together o its own by the way), designed to tell it exactly how often to fire those eight perfectly placed spark plugs. Of course, the steering wheel just by chance happened to be in the right location, while also connecting the front-end with it's front axle, ball joints, tie rods and perfectly synchronizing the movement of the tires. The tires by the way also all happen to be perfectly sized, with identical tread, perfect air pressure (how did air pressure even get in there by the way??) made of just the right rubber material, while perfectly balanced and with perfect alignment all by itself. All along the way to turn those tires somehow a power steering pump made itself, with belt and fluid with it's case and cap filed just where it needs to go. The doors so one can get inside the car are perfectly fitted and actually open with the lift of a handle. An armrest also somehow conveniently evolved, while still looking and smelling brand new. Of course rather than just look at this beauty, it actually runs and will even automatically shift into different gears because low and behold there is a TRANSMISION too. One that somehow and some way just perfectly connected with the motor which somehow and some way has eight pistons, a crank shaft, fuel injectors, cam shaft, a perfectly sealed even (though removable) head so that the transmission actually has something to shift for. Of course you need high octane, fresh, clean gasoline to run the entire thing, but low and behold it has a full tank of just that. How bout that? In fact believe it or not, the fuel tank has a fuel line too, that just so happens to be connected to a fuel filter which leads it right to eight perfectly fitted and located fuel injectors, which somehow and some way are attached to the engine itself that is still perfectly situated in the front of that automobile that just happened to make itself.


    Unbelievable there is also a hood, with an outside and inside hood latch that allows you to look at the motor that evolved on its own. All the while fitting perfectly and symmetrically into perfect place. In another incredible act of chance, there is a gas pedal too that when pressed carefully lets that amazingly complex machine (that just happened by chance) to move forward. Of course once you did get in it and realized this amazing machine can actually take you wherever you wish to go, you have another serious problem; whoops, how do you stop it? Big problem. Well lookey here!... there is a BRAKE PEDAL right next to the gas pedal that just so happens to connect to four disc brakes that also are perfectly hitched to brake rotors, and calipers that are coincidentally just perfectly hooked up with those perfectly rounded and symmetrical tires that we already discovered earlier. And through some act of evolutionary coincidence, this braking system has a MASTER CYLINDER that just also happens to have the perfectly positioned brake lines, filled with just the correct kind and correct amount of brake fluid. Of course if it were instead power steering fluid, or transmission fluid or gasoline in them there brake lines it would not work one bit, and may even catch on fire, but since it has the exact consistency needed for brake fluid, it works like a charm. How bout that!


    There are several clear windows to look out from as well. Sure need those; glad they just happened to evolve just where they did too. Pretty amazing how the snails and other external forces just happened to get that red shiny paint job only where it is and not on the windows, would have a problem there for sure. And guess what else, inside it has heat and ac and rear defrost and windshield wiper blades, a fuel gauge, temp gauge, tachometer with speedometer, with perfectly located knobs that even say heat and ac and wiper speeds. How did that get here on it's own? Amazing aint it? And for some strange reason it needs to have some little piece of metal to turn the thing on, I believe they call it a KEY. Low and behold there IS a key, with the exact correct notches already in the perfectly located steering wheel. How bout all that, what an amazing coincidence!

    Obviously I could continue on with this for pages and pages Seekerboy. I am sure you can see the point. (Try as you may to miss the point), It would be silly, foolish, absurd, outrageous, strange, weird and just impossibly IGNORANT to believe ALL of these things just happened by blind chance, without any intelligence at all, creating one single, ready-to drive Red Chevrolet Corvette. If nobody on this board could be convinced of such a foolish idea with one automobile in the middle of nowhere, how then could people POSSIBLY believe that a FAR, FAR MORE complex universe and earth, filled with far more complicated life (than that single corvette) could possibly just happen by itself, through some evolutionary process, with absolutely no help from an intelligent source anywhere?


    The reality is, I would have a better chance of selling somebody on that car that just formed by itself, through abiogenesis (the supposed origination of life from lifeless matter) and then evolved with all the perfect pieces fitting together, than on the UNIVERSE and EARTH itself just happening to make themselves as well as all life forms upon the earth. A human being is far, far more complex that that car. With our immune systems, lymphatic systems, digestive systems, cardio systems with heart chambers and blood vessels, nervous systems, joints, muscles, tendons, brains with billions or neurons, eyes that see, ears that hear, nose that smells, fingers that feel, skin that sweats, mouth that tastes, chews and swallows. Feet, legs, knees that move and bend. Reproductive systems that can create new life etc etc on and on. The complexity of one human being puts that new Corvette to shame. Millions of time more complex. You get a scratch on that new car and you will visiting the body shop. Scratch or hurt yourself, and the body has the ability to actually heal itself. And you really hope to convince me it happened all by chance, with no designer, no intelligence behind it all, some primordial evolutionary soup like process? We haven't even started discussing the complexity and incredible order of our universe yet. Or the earth , how outstandingly complex yet perfectly harmonized it is. Photosynthesis, clouds and rain, the perfect tilt and rotational speed of the earth, perfect location of the sun, the moon, our orbit speed. The atmosphere, ozone layer, perfect amount of oxygen in the air. Gravity, food cycles, fire; all happened by blind chance? No intelligence required? Sorry but you are DEAD IN WATER.


    Lets talk about science for just a moment. The science where many get there beliefs that there is NO God, no maker because we cannot prove he exists. If science is so smart and such a trustworthy source, why cannot science then create life from non living matter? It has not been done. EVER. Not only can it not do such a thing as make life from non-living matter, even if all the parts are already there, in human form, animal form or any form, science cannot even GIVE LIFE BACK to the body that lost it prematurely through accidents, disease or any other disaster, or death through natural aging? With all the parts ALREADY TOGETHER, in front of them these scientists, they are still helpless and cannot make LIFE appear. Yet they insist that ALL life as we see it today, just happened by some series of chances, without ANY help from any intelligent source. How reasonable is this? Let me answer that, IT'S NOT.


    This is why I believe in an intelligent Creator rather than some evolutionary process. It makes sense. It is reasonable, it is logical and rational. To believe everything we see just happened by itself is none of those things in my sincere and honest opinion. Science cannot feed the poor nor cure the worlds problems either. It has not even cured AIDS, cancer, diabetes, heart disease, alzheimer's, fixed global warming, the ozone layer and tens of thousands of other issues. And people wish to put their trust in science when it comes to believing in a God or not? Sorry, I am not convinced.





















    http://kspark.kaist.ac.kr/Jesus/Intelligence%20&%20religion.htm

























    1- Everything which has a beginning has a cause. This an understood and accepted principle in human civilizations throughout the earth. If it had a beginning, then somebody or something made it. Fairly simple. The computers each of us are using at this moment had to be made by somebody. Mine was made by Apple, for example. But if there were no name mentioned at all, we still know that somebody had to make it. Design begets a designer.

    2- The Universe, including our earth (and all life upon the earth) had a beginning. Most scientists believe in the 'Big Bang" theory. While omitting God altogether, the common belief is that it did have a definite beginning and is still developing and expanding.

    3- Therefore, the Universe, that had a beginning, must also have a Cause. That Cause, in my opinion is God.

    4-The bible, in my opinion, is a reliable source of information. It claims to be authored by God. There is an abundance of evidence that it could be authored by God. As briefly listed on another thread (now defunct) here is a very short list of reasons why I believe the bible is from God and thus a reliable, trustworthy source of information today:

    "For me, the idea that all four of gospel writers just made up these accounts about Jesus Christ is not something I quickly buy into. The way they claim to have changed their lives, leaving many significant occupations and other personal things behind, leads me to believe they sure found something powerfully persuasive in this person called Christ. They also admit their mistakes which only adds to their credibility in my mind. Likewise the bible writer Paul; he certainly had something dramatic happen to him. He claims to have had a vision of Christ himself, became blind, went to Ananias as instructed and received his sight back. Then completely changed his direction from a persecutor of Christians to becoming an ardent member, one of the foremost of the apostles actually, spearheading the preaching of Christ to the Gentiles. The apostles did not even trust or believe him initially, which again, only adds to the believability in my opinion. I guess all of these writers could have just made these things up. That is possible. But it is also possible they happened just as were written. And if so, then we have some very interesting events taking place that would support Jesus' claim to be God's son, representing God himself. And if so, then what he says about God, about the earth, the future, life... can be and should be seriously considered. I would consider such a source as very reliable. Very trustworthy, *IF* these accounts about him are true.

    The many prophecies written that had exact fulfillments adds ever more weight to possibility of the bible being more than just some good book. The bible's statement that the earth is round, and that it hangs upon nothing, though men at that time believed the earth was flat, again adds value to the claim that it is from a higher source than men. Are all of these just mere coincidences? It is possible, I guess. But it's also possible that these facts give evidence that the source of these prophecies and scientific accuracies is from a much higher source than humans, who cannot predict the future with any kind of certainty. There are not only a couple of such prophecies, but literally hundreds which exact, detailed fulfillment.

    There is secular testimony as well, that Christ did exist and did perform miraculous events. The calendar we use today is based on the very year he was born. Just a coincidence? A person that really did not exist at all, or whose accomplishments were greatly exaggerated? Possible, I guess. But possibly not. The scriptures contain numerous accounts of miracles where people were brought back to life, sick and dying were healed, people were miraculously fed whether from food falling out of the sky or a few fishes feeding thousands, olive oil and bread jars that never ran out and other examples. Sea's were parted, were walked on and calmed down upon commands. You do not hear stories like this today, with hundreds of eye-witnesses to collaborate. This collection of books is available in over 2000 languages today. It the worlds best selling book of all time. The information contained is also very practical for those that wish to believe it and apply it. The Golden Rule for example. Children obeying their parents is another. Husbands loving their wives as their own bodies makes good marriages even better. And answer when mild turns away rage is a proven valuable principle in life. Jesus sermon on the mount in Matthew chapters 5-7 is still considered by many to be the greatest speech ever given. Priceless gems for many.

    Is it possible then that this bible is from God? I believe it is possible, and even very probable. If so, if it is from God himself, then the very question as to how life arrived is answered. Because it also tells the reader that God himself made these things that we see today. No soup-like conditions that somehow evolved into the beautiful yet complex systems we see surrounding us today. It answers many of man's perplexing questions. Does it answer everything? No, it does not. Yet it does say there are new scrolls to be opened. It talks about everlasting life being possible for those that believe and apply God's sons teachings in his life. A life where death and pain and mourning are things of the past. Not the kind of life we see today. It promises these things we see causing pain and death and heartaches will be done away completely and permanently. That is a beautiful hope. Many other answers, too many to list here are given as well. If the bible is true then, the human race has much to look forward to.

    For me, it does make sense. It does offer hope. It is worth putting my trust in. It does offer answers as well as a good measure of comfort. It is believable."


    5- The bible tells us that God had no beginning.

    Psalm 90:2 ...Even from time indefinite to time indefinite you are God.

    psalm 93:2... You are from time indefinite to time indefinite.

    Isaiah 57:15 ....God is ‘the high and lofty One that inhabiteth eternity’

    Revelation 15:3 ...righteous and true are your ways, King of Eternity.Revelation 15:3 ...righteous and true are your ways, King of Eternity.





    No human beings were there in the beginning of the universe to witness what exactly happened. Brilliant minds today can only guess and try to formulate theories. The bible says pointedly: "In the Beginning God Created the heavens and the earth". There is sound and reasonable reasons to believe, as many (including some of the most intellectual minds ever born) in Creation. That all life as we know it today was deigned by the only one who is not subject to time, the only one that never had a beginning. The only one that is not confined by space and bound by physical laws. Laws in which he created and therefore would not be subject to. None of which here is a stretch to either grasp, believe or understand. It makes sense to me. It is believable, logical and reasonable.


    Some like to suggest, "well you cannot prove this, so you really cannot say with any certainty that you believe this". And for those that do feel this way, I disagree. I should add, I "respectfully" disagree. I have no problems with others that feel differently than I. But I can believe and do believe in the existence of God, through more than just faith itself. Though faith is an integral part of this equation too. In fact it is needed to a degree. But there is also EVIDENCE, logical PROOF that an Intelligent Designer is responsible for all features of life today. Complex, intelligent, purposeful systems that reflect the intellect of that designer himself. There are numerous court cases that have gone to trial where all of the evidence is circumstantial. Perhaps no body has been found. Still, today's technology now allows trace evidences and other signs to give very convincing testimony that a crime was committed. Juries have been thoroughly and unitedly and fully convinced to convict criminals based on such outside, circumstantial evidence exclusively. Likewise then, there are numerous "evidences" that all life arrived due to the hand of a Master Designer. The complexity and uniformity, the order and structure, the harmony of system after system, feature after feature, from the smallest molecules to the incredible living breathing life forces surrounding us all, to the incredibly complex earth where so many systems are just perfectly balanced all working together to allow life to exist are evidences to me that somebody surely must be responsible. The far more complex, far more powerful and awe inspiring universe with star after star, planet after planet solar system after solar system all beautifully organized, with inconceivable, unimaginable amounts of power and energy, give further testimony, in my mind, that these things did not just "happen" through some unguided series of accidents. Just some fortuitous combination of circumstances. A blind fluke of good fortune?


    As Einstein astutely stated, "God does not play dice with the universe". So though we cannot see God, we can see EVIDENCE that he does indeed exist. Just as we cannot see our own brains or gravity, or oxygen etc... the evidence that these things are nonetheless real is overwhelming. For myself then, evidence that God exists is even more powerful. The evidence supports this belief for me.


















    Sure, there is a red corvette just sitting in North Dakota somewhere too...



  • proplog2
    proplog2

    I am an atheist because the concept of an almighty omnicient entity is incoherent.

    There is NO way that a finite mind can possibly determine the ultimate act of power or omnisicence that would serve as proof.

    Suppose an entity cured a sports arena full of down syndrome children. Can you conceive of an act greater than that? Yes. It's like stating the biggest number.

    You can never know if the miracle you are beholding is being performed by the "almighty" God or simply a "stronger than human entity>"

  • DanTheMan
    DanTheMan

    Vinny, your avalanche of words describing a Corvette notwithstanding, you failed to discern the point.

    If you insist that design requires a designer, no exceptions, then - who designed God?

    I personally do believe in a God because for me it makes the most logical sense to do so. (As did Einstein

    Well, not exactly. Although he did make statements such as, "God does not play dice with the universe", I'm pretty certain that he was only speaking of God metaphorically. Here's some other things he had to say on this subject that I think make his beliefs pretty clear:

    "I do not believe in a personal God and I have never denied this but have expressed it clearly."

    "I am a deeply religious nonbeliever."

    "The idea of a personal God is quite alien to me and seems even naive"

  • nvrgnbk
    nvrgnbk
    Vinny, your avalanche of words

    I couldn't read that. ADD is a bitch! LOL! When God shows up, we'll no longer have anything to debate. In

    the meantime, we'll continue to discuss his/her/its absence and/or non-existence.

    Nvr

  • Vinny
    Vinny

    Dan the man said:..."Vinny, your avalanche of words describing a Corvette notwithstanding, you failed to discern the point. If you insist that design requires a designer, no exceptions, then - who designed God?"


    **** Perhaps you should try READING the actual post before COMMENTING on it Danny the man. I answered that question in detail. Like the answer or not like it, it's there in black and white print.


    And, if you'd like a detailed reply to a less than casual subject, such as evidence that there is a God out there, then I'm afraid one or two paragraphs are not going to cut it.


    Vinny

  • LtCmd.Lore
    LtCmd.Lore

    Well vinny, that's a pretty interesting arguement that you copied and pasted for us. (Just pick any sentence in that illustration and google it, and you'll see what I mean.)

    Unfortunately it is based on a completely incorrect concept of evolution. And makes the common mistake of equating naturalness with randomness. While it's true that mutations are mostly random, natural selection is anything but random.

    Plus, the car doesn't reproduce at all, therefore removing any chance of mutations, or progressions from simpler organisms/vehicles.... It's about as illogical as assuming a human spontaniously formed as a fully grown adult from the dust around him. (Sound familiar?)

    And, you say that it's a perfectly formed automobile... I have never seen a 'perfect' animal, they all have flaws. Every species has plenty of room for improvement.

    So in short, here's the problems with your illustration:

    1. It operates purely according to random chance. Unlike evolution.
    2. It is an example of single-step, rather than cumulative, selection. Unlike evolution.
    3. It is a saltationary jump - an end product entirely unlike the beginning product. Unlike evolution.

    Also you used a mechanical object made from metal and man made materials, not natural things like cells and tissue. That's probably also a serious problem... I'll look it up.

    EVEN IF it started out as a wheel, and was capable of reproduction and mutation, and was subject to natural selection. It still wouldn't work, because cars are MADE FOR humans, whereas every lifeform in existence evolved to make ITS OWN survival more likely, not something else. Cars would be incapable of surviving without humans.

    Trees don't make fruit in order to serve humans, they make fruit because animals will take the fruit and therefore spread the seeds and help that species of tree survive.

    Lastly, this is an arguement against complexity. The car it to complex to form without a designer, therefore the human is to complex to form without a designer... but it ignores the fact that ANY god that created the humans would ALSO be extremely complex. Most likely more complex. And so therefore, it is just as unlikely for and all-knowing all-powerfull god to apear out of thin air, as it is for biological humans to appear out of thin air. (Which it NOT what atheists think anyway.)

    So then: "Sorry but you are DEAD IN WATER"

    Maybe tomorrow I'll confront your other extremely long arguements...

    _____

    I can imagine a world where God's existence would be an undeniable fact.

    I can imagine a world where cities in heathen nations regularly exploded in flames for no apparent reason; a world where we could go to the Middle East and see the entrance to the Garden of Eden, locked and barred and guarded by a flaming sword, with misty green Paradise visible in the distance beyond the gates; a world where angels flew alongside planes blowing trumpets and calling on sinners to repent. I can imagine a world of miracles and spirits, where faith healers could cure severed spinal cords or regenerate lost limbs, where prophets called fire from heaven, sent rain, parted seas and multiplied loaves and fishes, where voices boomed from the sky in answer to prayers, and where the entire geologic record consisted of fossils randomly jumbled throughout strata of flood-deposited sediments. I can readily imagine a world like this.

    However, we don't live in that world.

    In fact, the world we live in seems to be a distinctly natural one. There are no prophets, no angels, no Garden of Eden in the Middle East, and no trace of a global flood in the geologic record. Claims of miracles invariably turn out to be either trivial, anecdotal or spurious. The sadly gullible souls who trust in the powers of faith healers often wind up worse off than they were before, even dead. The era of true divine intervention, when miracles were real and the presence of God was undeniable, seems to be always in the past, always receding further into history.

    In short, the world we live in is essentially indistinguishable from one in which there is no supernatural at all.

    ____ I openly admit, that last bit was taken from another site:

    here it is if you're interested.

    LtCmd.Lore

  • LtCmd.Lore
    LtCmd.Lore
    **** Perhaps you should try READING the actual post before COMMENTING on it Danny the man. I answered that question in detail. Like the answer or not like it, it's there in black and white print.
    Please read the 'Huge posts' section from the how to think like a fundy website, under 'debating techniques'.

Share this

Google+
Pinterest
Reddit