Oompa do you love your wife as the person she is? What a person believes is a very personal thing and I think on this site we can see this for ourselves easily but not for others around us. If your wife could just change everything she deeply believes just on your say so because she loves you, then it doesn't say much for her depth of character.
My ex found me too independant! I now get on quite well with him and his new partner, she is the complete opposite to me, I took them to dinner and said they could have whatever they wanted. She at first said she wanted the scampi and looked like she really wanted it but then my ex chose cottage pie and quickly she changed to have the same as him, this is typical of how their relationship works and often my ex says it's nice to have someone worship him and she certainly does, if he asked her to believe in UFO's she would.
What if you can by pushing all the emotional buttoms force her to your way of life and beliefs, would that be fair? Maybe what we have here is a true test of how much you love your partner? enough to let her be her own person in mind as well as in body?