In order to be an EXCLUSIVE religious body with CENTRAL AUTHORITY Jehovah's Witnesses must create a FOUNDATIONAL cause for that authority.
1.The first christians had as a foundation their own belief in the ORAL STORIES told about Jesus as Messiah.
2.The Catholic Church had as a foundation the teaching that Jesus himself appointed Peter as 1st Pope. Once you buy in to that you ALSO
must accept their self-created DOCTRINE of Magisterium: the Pope and Bishops determine what is true without error.
3.The Protestant revolution had to replace this foundation.
The central authority of Pope and his inerrancy needed to be replaced by something. But--what?
Martin Luther invented a counter-weapon. He developed his own idea: SOLA SCRIPTURA. The BIBLE now became inerrant. All a person of faith needed
was to read the bible BY HIMSELF and the spirit of god would give him the rest.
4.Protestant christianity (applying Luther's doctrine) split into denominations with different OPINIONS using the bible alone.
5.Higher critics pointed out thousands of errors and contradiction in the bible. THIS SERVED TO REFUTE THE ASSERTION OF INERRANCY.
6.Cults immediately sprang up to take advantage of the AUTHORITY GAP.
A. Cults assert a different SOURCE for their authority: a special selection by God enabling them (the cult leader) to infallibly interpret the bible
B. When predictions prove false these cult leaders tighten their hold by asserting a doomsday SCARE AUTHORITY instead
Jehovah's Witnesses tried to be both a Magisterium and use an Ad Hoc Doctrine as a prop (Faithful and discreet slave). Their Governing Body
uses the bible (declared inerrant) PLUS this Magisterium (selection by Jesus in 1919) PLUS ever tightening authority and exclusion.
The bible is only a mirage of authority and source for JW doctrines. Their GB Magisterium is really the only foundation for authority they currently have going for them.
Since that GB authority has proved fallible time and time again....they can now only use SCARE TACTICS (drumbeat about death at Armageddon) to control and choke off competition from other denominations.
The same theme has followed Christianity from the very beginning. It always ends the same way.
BY OVERSTATING THE SOURCE OF AUTHORITY the central leader sets themselves up to fail and to fall.