What was there before the Big Bang?
Quiet.
What was there before the Big Bang?
by Brokeback Watchtower 88 Replies latest watchtower beliefs
-
-
Island Man
There may have been a big crunch. Maybe the universe is eternal and oscillates between banging and crunching. Bang --> Expand --> Stop --> Recede --> Crunch --> (Repeat) -
OUTLAW
What was there before the Big Bang?
....This One Lonesome Planet..
.............Floating in Space..
-
Coded Logic
you cant have something come from nothing.
-SWNHow do you know this? Have you ever observed a lack of space time and energy? How would you know how it behaves?
I'd recommend you do a little reading on entropy. It doesn't just imply that we can get something from nothing. Rather, it means that "nothing" is inherently unstable and will always produce something.
Our intuitions are useless here. We have no prior experience in the formation of universes that we can draw upon. "That doesn't sound right to me" is not a valid objection.
-
-
Heaven
What was there before the Big Bang?
Quiet.
In Space, no one can hear you scream. -
-
prologos
CL: "--it means that "nothing" is inherently unstable and will always produce something. and when you have instability it implies change, acceleration, and that means means a priori you have time, even times squared to move through. -
sowhatnow
coded, I never claimed to know.
[ i wish people would stop assuming and putting words in my mouth]
you said
'Rather, it means that "nothing" is inherently unstable and will always produce something'.
There you go. that scentence makes much more sense.
then you said
Our intuitions are useless here. We have no prior experience in the formation of universes that we can draw upon.
"That doesn't sound right to me" is not a valid objection.
But thats the same thing.lol
we have not enough exp. which is why it doesnt sound just right....yet
[ ill read about entropy]
-
Fisherman
What exploded? something or nothing? If something then what is its substance and how long did it exist before the the big bang and what caused it to explode. If nothing then how in the world can nothing explode into something and what caused nothing to become something.
