I am with you 100 % Simon. I do hope that Britain and France will institute the same checks for Americans entering these countries.
I am mad, because I need to renew my passport, and because of this new procedure, I am supposed to obtain a "Secure" passport or whatever term they use, meaning that I have to present myself at the French Consulat, instead of doing it by mail as I have always done. For me it is an 8 or more hours trip, and I don't see how I can do that. So I have no valid passport right now...