good question....
the thing that we used to look at was meeting attendance mostly....
i have to laugh when i think about one fellow elder that used to discretely roam the KH during the watchtower study to see if any attending DF ones had underlined their WT...that way you KNEW that they were really studying and therefore, showing repentance...
funny, when i was trying to get reinstated for 18 months, i actually HIGHLITED in FLORESCENT hiliters my lesson...didn't do a damn bit of good, LOL they made me wait to TEACH me patience and humility..LOL
seems that some self righteous, sadistic, holier than thou elders love to see DFd ones crawl back on their hands and knees....i had the chairman of my JC actually stuff my reinstatement request letter into his briefcase for three weeks before he even showed it to the other bros on the committee..
bottom line is: you really have no idea whether the person is repentant or not..guess you just have to "let the holy spirit move you" in these matters if you're on the JC handling a reinstatement plea..
formerly a "high achiever in the org", you can now sign me....
out and free, and living life in the "now".. yeaaaaaaaa!!!!
btw, there is life after DF'g. there is also life after divorce...and, yes, there is also life after alcohol...