Some deep reasonings here.
I guess the overwhelming feeling coming through, is the need for the WTBTS to recognise that the methodology in dealing with its members, is not conducive to an interchange of honest worship or freedom of expression of heart.
With regard to the shunning doctrine, the principle of expulsion from any organisation for not adhering to its rules is legally and morally correct, and to be fair, I dont have a problem with it. However, the stated reason for expulsion,the only reason for expulsion is unrepentance, ie, not ceasing an action or course of conduct, and not willing to change....is not adhered to. Persons are actually expelled for fornication, for stealing for lying etc...which is contrary to the scripturally stated procedure. Along with this, is the then enforced practice of shunning, and it is taken to ridiculous lengths, it destroys relationships, puts everything on a basis of conditional love, and is unscriptural.
Then we have the blood tranfusion issue.
Then the neutrality issue.
Then.......
But the question is...do we have anything to reform?
Are the basic tenets, doctrinal understanding, channelling from God really there within the WTBTS?
If it is, then do have to just wait for Jehovah to rectify it..
And if it isnt..what is to stop us, members of this board who still believe in a creator, starting our own congregation and interchanging spiritual nuggets without interpretation or condemnation?
Im just saddened to know that in the event that this did happen, some people who know that they have the true message, will try and hijack it for their own ends....
Maybe we really are on our own.